Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns

Clothespin Cookies - Clothes Pins, Cream Horns, Lady Locks, Fingers
Click to enlarge

Purchase

Retail Price: $40.00
Sale Price: $24.49
Product ID : clothespin-lady-locks-fingers
2 Dozen Per Box


Add To Wish List


Description

Melt in your mouth, super delicious sweet buttercream filled, flaky, yet soft, fluffy pastry, dusted with confectioners powdered sugar. Just as fantabulous as the reviews below say. These heavenly treats are the meaning of "labor of love", deeply rooted in proud Eastern European, Italian, and Greek family traditions for special occasions, most notably along side the kolachi cookies and large kolachi rolls at Wedding Cookie Tables in Youngstown and Pittsburgh, and Christmas, Thanksgiving, Easter, bridal & baby showers, birthdays, graduation, and the list goes on. Usually the first empty plate. Now a year round best seller enjoyed as a daily treat. Hide them Try them cold - right out of the freezer - you'll never switch back. Nobody better lay a finger on my ladyfingers.

What You Get: A great thing about these classic pastries is they're like snowflakes, no two are alike... varying in size, weight, amount of filling (which may not reach the ends of the pastry, or it can spill out), flaky/soft, light or dark in color, etc... There are many variations, ours may not be like other recipes you've had but we promise the highest quality. Each unit is approximately 10 oz per box of 2 dozen.

We don't believe in preservatives, but for your safety it's a must in this product. INGREDIENTS: PUFF PASTRY DOUGH (FLOUR, MARGARINE, WATER, SEA SALT), SUGAR, FLOUR, BUTTER, EGG WHITES, CORN STARCH, CALCIUM ALGINATE, GUM TRAGACANTH, CITRIC ACID, POTASSIUM SORBATE (PRESERVATIVES)

Free shipping, coupon codes, and quantity discounts, if offered, are valid per order of all items shipped to the same address. Quantity discounts not valid by phone.

Product Reviews

Reviewed by Rod Goins
05/23/2019 - 09:15:27 PM
Outstandingly made and delisious
Butter Maid has become my go to bakery for both gifts and events. The product is fresh and well made, and delivered on time. I highly recommend you consider a purchase.
Reviewed by Joy
05/23/2019 - 07:38:02 PM
Clothespin cookies
LOVED THESE....REMINDED ME OF WHEN MY MOTHER IN LAW BAKED THEM.
Reviewed by Regina I Finney
05/23/2019 - 06:48:55 AM
Clothesline Cookies
My mother used to buy cream horns for herself and my brother-because I hated them! I saw these online and thought my husband might like them as a birthday treat. Oops! I tried one, then proceeded to eat most of the rest! Loved them! Like nothing I've had before! Just wish they weren't so expensive. But that's probably a good thing for my weight.
Reviewed by Karen
05/22/2019 - 06:40:36 PM
Addictive cookies!
Clothespin cookies arrived in perfect condition and disappeared quickly. Delicious!
Reviewed by David A Wojnar
05/22/2019 - 01:00:12 PM
LadyLocks
I wish they were bigger. Delicious, creamy goodness.
Reviewed by Clinton Cavanaugh
05/22/2019 - 12:49:41 PM
Youngstown cookie table!
I live in Boston, but grew up in the next town over from Buttermaid Bakery. When I couldn't be at my Godson's engagement party in D.C. this past weekend, I sent a variety of two dozen cookies--including the clothespins--so the cookie table could be my stand-in. All the cookies were a huge hit. Thank you!
Reviewed by Janice Allen
05/21/2019 - 07:30:27 PM
Clothes pin cookies
My ultimate pleasure. Received in a reasonable amount of time. Love the Clothes Pin Cookies. Hmmm good. Thanks
Reviewed by Barbara Ruhe
05/21/2019 - 12:11:20 PM
Not just like mine...
but OK. I made the best but took two days! Yours would be good to whoever ever tasted mine. A tad expensive. I sold mine for $1 a dozen 20 yrs ago. At age 81 just can't do it anymore!! Love the kifli!
Reviewed by Kathleen
05/18/2019 - 06:38:01 PM
Melt in your mouth
Lady locks were smaller than I am used to, but were absolutely delicious. Crisp, flaky pastry and the filling is so creamy they just melt in your mouth.
Reviewed by Susan Balden
05/16/2019 - 11:03:10 PM
clothespin cookies
This order was as wonderful as all the others I have had from the past!!!! My Mother in law has found them easy to eat and she enjoys the very much. She is 90 and can't eat a whole lot of things. Thank you so much for them being on sale!! Made Mother Day perfect for her!!!!
Reviewed by Stephanie
05/16/2019 - 09:39:46 PM
Clothes pins
These were way better than I expected. Wanted to try something new and these were the best thing ever. The cream in the center was amazing very tasty. Nice crunch to the cookie. The powder sugar was like icing on the cake. Wonderful would definitely recommend.
Reviewed by Linda Dragan
05/16/2019 - 07:11:27 AM
Clothespin cookies
Just delicious. Never has anything like it. Everyone fights over them. The family to whom I gave these, just loves how light & tastety they are.
Reviewed by Connie
05/15/2019 - 06:06:18 PM
Clothespin cookies
This was my second order of these delicious cookies and it will not be my last! They are addictive! Delivery was fast and the cookies are always packed well so they aren’t damaged when they are delivered. Definitely satisfied
Reviewed by kurtswife1977@yahoo.com
kurtswife1977@yahoo.com bought "Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns" on our website
05/15/2019 - 05:05:15 PM
Clothespin cookies
These are wonderful. I bought them and had them out for Easter. Everyone loved them. Them are light. And flaky, not too sweet!
Reviewed by Antonia
05/12/2019 - 06:12:35 PM
Cream Rolls
Oh how delicious !!!!
Reviewed by Michele Murphy
05/12/2019 - 04:51:35 PM
Clothespin cookies
I come from a family with bakers.I had an Aunt who owned and ran an ethnic bakery in our neighborhood and was quite successful. So I had to try these, but I was a little disappointed because my Aunt used real whip cream. The pastry was very good and light, but the filling I did not care for. I give them 3 stars
Reviewed by jenette
05/10/2019 - 12:18:21 AM
back again
these cream horns are really good...do not pass them up..
Reviewed by Jo A Powers
05/09/2019 - 08:29:19 PM
Closepin Cookies
They are small but do they pack in the flavor. Love the buttercream filling. I will continue to order them
Reviewed by jandelgolf@aol.com
jandelgolf@aol.com bought "Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns" on our website
05/08/2019 - 10:46:38 PM
Temptation!
The one temptation that makes me go off my eating plan (diet).
Just can't resist them and don't want to.
Reviewed by Kathy Walsh
05/08/2019 - 02:03:18 PM
Pleasantly Surprised
I was concerned about how these would hold up in shipping. They were so delicious and light that we just ordered another batch.
Reviewed by Kathy Braun
05/06/2019 - 09:15:53 PM
Clothespin cookies
I was so excited to receive my order and you guys at Buttermaid exceeded my expectations. These cookies were delicious, the packaging was great. My cookies arrived whole and not broken up. My husband loved these. Thank you for a quality product that reminds me so much of home.
Reviewed by Helen Charbonneau
05/04/2019 - 11:45:46 AM
cream horns
They were smaller than I expected looking at the picture. But I liked the crisp little cookie with the cream.
Reviewed by Joann
05/04/2019 - 10:39:40 AM
Cream Horns
Awesome, amazing, melt in your mouth. I relived my childhood eating these amazing Cream Horns.
Reviewed by Peggy
05/02/2019 - 09:37:57 PM
Nice Little Cookie
The cookies are very small, but sweet. I think a larger cookie would be too sweet. They reminded be of a Bear Claw pastry you get at a bakery.
These were enjoyed by all.
Reviewed by Terrence
05/02/2019 - 06:29:08 PM
Closepin Cookies
Every once in a while, I make these and now there is no reason to ever make a total mess of my kitchen again. They taste great and are freezable. Down side is that 2 dozen can disappear in a short period of time. One should order 2 to 3 sets to make sure there will be enough before the next order.
Reviewed by Barbara Huber
05/01/2019 - 09:39:01 PM
Heavenly “Lady Locks”!
These delicious “Lady Locks”, as we called them when I was growing up in Southwestern Pennsylvania, are an authentic replica of my sister’s. She would spend hours in the kitchen, carefully winding a delicate ribbon of pastry around a tin foil covered clothespin for baking. She would watch them carefully as they baked, waiting for the exact moment when they were perfectly done - firm, but not brown. Then she would fill them with homemade thick buttery cream, dust with powder sugar, chill and serve. It was like watching a new mother with her newborn baby. One can taste the love and care she put into these cookies, and can taste it in your cookies, too.
Reviewed by Jacqueline
05/01/2019 - 04:20:43 PM
Clothespins
The were awesome.
Reviewed by Mary Ann Nissen
05/01/2019 - 04:09:48 PM
Just like mom made
Being in California for almost 50 years coming from western PA I had forgotten about these cookies. Used to help mom make them for Christmas. These were just like those excep ours were a little longer, the length of the clothespins. Great taste
Reviewed by Sophia
05/01/2019 - 01:39:01 PM
Loved cream filling
They were very light and tasty. Would definitely order again.
Reviewed by Patti Takacs
05/01/2019 - 11:39:38 AM
Clothespin cookies
They were to die for. A friend made them for me years ago. I've never seen any ad for them until yours.
Reviewed by Robin
05/01/2019 - 09:21:28 AM
Gift
While I did not taste them, I am told by the people that I gifted them to that they were absolutely delicious and fresh.
Reviewed by Pat Barnhart
05/01/2019 - 08:07:37 AM
My Favorite
It is my favorite Y-Town cookie.
Reviewed by Judith M Carlson
05/01/2019 - 12:01:37 AM
Delicious
If I could I would order these every week. They are so good.
Reviewed by Sharon
04/30/2019 - 02:23:20 PM
clothes pin cookies
These cookies were so good and fresh. Everyone enjoyed them.
Reviewed by Linda
04/30/2019 - 09:11:49 AM
a perfect "sweet"
Traditional in our family for many, many years but all of the "original" bakers in family gone now. These cookies were packed well for shipping and arrived intact and were DELICIOUS. Will order again!
Reviewed by Joyce N Reese
04/29/2019 - 08:10:31 PM
Fantastic
My mother in law always made these for special occasions. They were just as good as hers, she called hers lady locks, also. It seemed like it took her a couple of days to make them with the dough, clothespins, and filling. Fantastic!!!!
Reviewed by K10lover
04/29/2019 - 04:06:22 PM
Clothespin cookies
My husband was in heaven! Delicious cookies! Great buttercream filling!
Reviewed by Kathy Adelman
04/29/2019 - 09:56:14 AM
Fabulous
This is not the typical bakery. Each and every item I have purchased is just like “ Baba” made! I love it!
Reviewed by Diana
04/28/2019 - 09:28:48 PM
Clothespin Cookies...you can't eat just one!
What can I say...these were AWESOME!!!!
Reviewed by Michelle Oldham
04/28/2019 - 03:49:39 PM
Lady Locks
These were absolutely delicious. I will be ordering several dozens of these for my deughter’s Cookie table in Atlanta.
Reviewed by katkins7504@yahoo.com
katkins7504@yahoo.com bought "Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns" on our website
04/28/2019 - 02:30:45 AM
Lady Locks
Delicious. Will order again.
Reviewed by pms
04/27/2019 - 11:07:52 PM
Deception
The Lady Fingers were super small. The photo made them look much larger. Very disappointed. They did have a nice flavor.
Reviewed by Mickie
04/27/2019 - 04:29:40 PM
Lady Locks
Purchased these as a surprise for my husband because they are his favorite cookie. He said they were the best he ever had!
Reviewed by Krista Hess
04/27/2019 - 03:01:50 PM
Totally Scrumptious!
I first tried this type of cookie many years ago while vacationing in the Outer Banks. That bakery closed, and I wasn't able to find anything close, until now. These are absolutely delicious! I don't want to share them at all!
Reviewed by Christine
04/27/2019 - 12:06:57 AM
‘Clothing Pin’ cookies for Easter
I never had tasted they before therefore I have tried one. It’s really delicious and light.
Reviewed by christa
04/26/2019 - 09:05:38 PM
butter creme fingers
The butter crème fingers were melt-in-your-mouth delicious! Will definitely reorder.
Reviewed by Wanda
04/25/2019 - 10:49:43 PM
Awesomeness
These melt in your mouth and leave you feeling loved. Well worth the cost!
Reviewed by Donna Gendwr
04/25/2019 - 12:59:07 PM
OMG I Love Butter Maid
They have the best clothespin cookies and kolachi I've had in many years. Takes me back to when my Great Grandmother from Croatia was living in Struthers, Ohio.
Reviewed by Julie P
04/25/2019 - 09:09:26 AM
Great little pastries
I'm not from Ohio, so these were new to me, but I do miss the quality bakeries of my childhood in Indiana so I thought these might do the trick. They came very quickly and I was pleased with them. They are small, but that made it a good two bite treat. I will be ordering more from ButterMaid!
Reviewed by CaroleJ
04/24/2019 - 02:38:15 PM
Delectable
As this was my first order, I ordered several items that my mother used to bake. All three were absolutely delicious. I shared them with my family on Easter, and they were a big hit!
Reviewed by Beverly Peck
04/24/2019 - 09:27:42 AM
Clothespins
Absolutely delicious. My husband likes ladylocks and these were like mini ladylocks. Light pastry, not soggy. Filling was devine.
Reviewed by Mary Roberts
04/24/2019 - 02:13:42 AM
Yummy!
These were very tasty. I have never had this type of cookie before so I didn’t know what to expect. They were a bit smaller than I thought they would be. But that didn’t diminish the great flavor. I just had to eat a few more to satisfy my craving!
Reviewed by Frances Bacon
04/23/2019 - 07:31:05 PM
Ladies Fingers
Have not had these since leaving the Pittsburgh area in 1985. These are the best I have ever had. Wonderful.
Reviewed by Nan
04/23/2019 - 02:15:53 PM
First Time
This was the first time that I ever tried this kind of cookie and it was like no other I have ever had! The first bite reminded me of a cannoli, but definitely better! They were thin and delicious! The creme was so light and addictive! I had to restrain my self from eating all of them to share with my family!
Reviewed by Virginia Trusty
04/23/2019 - 10:10:47 AM
dry
dissappointed in these, very dry
Reviewed by PapaT3800
PapaT3800 bought "Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns" on our website
04/22/2019 - 10:49:22 AM
Memories
We sent these to our son for Easter to remind him of his childhood favorites. He says they were just lie mine---so take that as a compliment!!!
Reviewed by Bea
04/22/2019 - 04:41:13 AM
Clothes pin cookies
Extremely good!
Reviewed by Linda M.
04/21/2019 - 10:45:26 PM
Clothespin Cookies
Got 2 dozen. They were delicious. A little smaller than I anticipated but delicious.
Reviewed by Linda
04/21/2019 - 10:33:32 PM
Great cookies
The clothespin cookies are fabulous! The first time I bought them I was thinking what am I going to do with two dozen cookies. They lasted me less than a week! SO GOOD!
Reviewed by Diane
04/20/2019 - 04:03:04 PM
Closepin cookies
Very good. Liked the smaller sizing. Not exceptionally sweet.
Reviewed by Kathy Zeis
04/20/2019 - 08:59:28 AM
Delicious
These were sinfully good. They were like little cream horns which is a favorite of mine. Will reorder for special occasions. I can’t keep them around cause I’ll eat them all.
Reviewed by Jean H
04/18/2019 - 12:40:51 PM
Heaven
All I can say is Oh my Gosh! These were so delicious!! I couldn't stop eating them and had to hide them from my husband so he wouldn't eat them all. Besides, he had the apple kolachi roll and he chowed on it!
Reviewed by William Yacso
04/18/2019 - 08:53:49 AM
Just very good
They were Just very Good but need to be a little bit bigger we love them
Reviewed by Deborah
04/17/2019 - 02:48:23 PM
great, the best ever
These are delicious! I was pleasantly surprised, not all bakeries are the same this Butter Maid Bakery is the absolute BEST!Z
Reviewed by Chester
04/17/2019 - 10:57:51 AM
Awesome
This was only my third order . . . and it was awesome just like my first two orders from Butter Maid Bakery. They seem to have a flavor that not only tastes great, but also brings back special memories from the past.
Reviewed by FJL
04/15/2019 - 03:36:13 PM
CLOTHESPIN COOKIES
SO SO GOOD AND FRESH.
Reviewed by Joyce
04/15/2019 - 02:25:24 PM
Lady Locks
I was a little concerned about shipping these delicate locks but they arrived in perfect shape. They are so delicate on the outside but the centers are perfect, smooth and creamy. Just delightful .
Reviewed by Lynn
04/15/2019 - 01:23:50 PM
Clothespin Cookies
I ordered two(2) of the 2 dozen boxes of the clothespin cookies. However, only one was sent. They sent another nut filled type Cookie.
They were both delicious, but so disappointing not to have received the two boxes of the clothespin cookies.
Reviewed by Connie
04/14/2019 - 04:05:43 PM
Fabulous
I ordered these cookies for the first time they are absolutely fabulous so delicious we ate them all could not stop eating them dreamy....
Reviewed by Mary Ann
04/14/2019 - 03:27:42 PM
Lady Locks
A VERY BIG disappointment! Not flaky at all, small, and the filling is more like icing. Will never order again.Over all too expensive for the size. I do bake and have made these cookies and were much better but I wanted to give yours a try.
Reviewed by Dorothy Jackson
04/14/2019 - 12:08:56 PM
Delicious
OMG! These cream horns were absolutely delicious. They certainly didn’t last very long.
Reviewed by Rose M. Wiege
04/11/2019 - 10:26:43 AM
Closepin filled cookies, yummy
I am thrilled with my order - 6 dozen, in my freezer for a wedding in May for the Cookie Table. I cheated and tasted one, so delicious. Wonderful service also.
Reviewed by Dmk7078
Dmk7078 bought "Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns" on our website
04/10/2019 - 11:51:56 PM
Tasty treats
I served the clothespin cookies with other dessert at a wedding shower and everyone agreed they were tasty and light! A nice treat!
Reviewed by Sharon Rosati
04/08/2019 - 09:32:38 PM
They flooded my mind with decades of wedding cookie tables.
I didnt have high expectations for these as compared to my family's version. I was pleasantly surprised. They arrived in perfect condition. Not 1 broken. The horn was a little softer than homemade but was tender crisp and excellent flavor. There was no sogginess from the filling which had a distinct butter flavor. Yes, they were really small for the money. But good ingredients are expensive as is expert handling. I would buy again if were on sale but I don't have enough to get them except as an occasional treat. Overall, a successful experience.
Reviewed by Stu
04/08/2019 - 05:14:06 PM
Clothes pin cookies.
In the words of one of the Seinfeld characters, "the best Jerry, the best"
Reviewed by Char
04/06/2019 - 08:22:02 PM
Tasty
So so good closepin
Reviewed by Dawn
04/03/2019 - 08:34:24 PM
Little Rolls Of Perfection!
So addictive! These are the so delightful make sure you order more than 1 box as they go fast!
Reviewed by Janet1946
Janet1946 bought "Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns" on our website
03/30/2019 - 03:22:50 PM
Clothespin Cookies
The cookies were wonderful and much better than the ones I can buy at Giant Eagle bakery, but the ones at Giant Eagle are half your price.
Reviewed by Jo Ann Hartos
03/28/2019 - 08:51:15 AM
The best
These will be home quickly, they are delicious
Reviewed by Fran
03/27/2019 - 06:40:53 AM
Disappointed
I grew up in Youngstown, make clothespin cookies all my life, so I was excited when I saw these. Sad example of what clothespins really are. These are tiny (suppose to be the size of a clothes pin) the lack of filling was sad. I will NOT order these again. I will take the hours to make the real thing.
Reviewed by jenbar420@aol.com
jenbar420@aol.com bought "Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns" on our website
03/27/2019 - 01:08:16 AM
taste of heaven
i love cream horns, but can rarely find them....so i was very pleased to find them here online..i lived in ohio for many years, and knew of the bakery...so when i got them i had to try them right away...i ate about 6 before i had to put them away..thank you...
Reviewed by SJK
03/12/2019 - 11:08:32 AM
Tasty
Just about bite sized. My parents made these when I was a kid and I have not been able to find good ones since, until now.
Reviewed by Ann
03/04/2019 - 06:26:24 PM
Lady Locks
Again, a wonderfully delicious addition to the Wedding Cookie Table at my daughters wedding. Old school excellence! So pretty! Delicious...every bite!! Of course, not 1 leftover!! These really rate 10 Stars!!
Reviewed by Beth
03/04/2019 - 05:01:08 PM
Too sweet for me
These were shipped very quickly but when I tasted them they were a bit too sweet - however I gave them to be of my patients who enjoyed them
Reviewed by Linda Kelley
03/04/2019 - 02:55:13 PM
clothes pins
wow these are like creme puffs only better, wish they were bigger, I love them, eat lot 1 sitting, thanks so much for making these so good, and fast shipping.
Reviewed by Annamarie
02/25/2019 - 03:51:04 PM
Taste of home
This is not the first time I have purchased things from your company but I will tell you this I have never been disappointed the people that I have shared your product with are totally taken back in time and enjoy it so much thank you so much for being so wonderful and having such a great taste from the past for the people that I love
Reviewed by Ed Emerson
02/24/2019 - 09:42:35 PM
WOW!
These are just like I remember as a kid! Flaky, perfectly filled! Worth the calories!
Reviewed by Ed Slusser
02/24/2019 - 08:05:50 PM
Big Hit!
We ordered the clothes pins for my son's wedding reception. They arrived fresh and packaged well. My
Italian aunt made these when I was little. Yours were just as delicious. Thank you for making the cookie table special!
Reviewed by Mariaelena Smith
02/23/2019 - 09:22:51 AM
Awesome
My mother and aunts handled down the recipes to me from my grandma. I have been baking these cookies for years but now I can really just sit back and enjoy these awesome cookies. They taste like I made them. Thanks for doing the work for me.
Reviewed by Mary
02/22/2019 - 01:47:16 PM
Great bakery
Fabulous, great cookie
Reviewed by Cindy Canipe
02/21/2019 - 12:41:43 PM
Clothes pins/ladyfingers
I have sent these to my mom for several years for special occasions. She adores them and is always excited to receive something a little different and so delicious. They arrive timely and fresh. Thank you.
Reviewed by dont buy
02/20/2019 - 11:08:34 AM
expensive lesson
Very disappointed no flavor unbelieveable that this is from the some bakery that has delicious nutrolls
An expensive learning experience
doesn't even rate one star
Reviewed by PILOT JACK
02/18/2019 - 03:59:37 PM
TO DIE FOR
I am addicted...3 different orders of cloths pin cookies and kolachi at 60 bucks a pop. TRUST ME IT IS ALL WORTH...
Keep up the GREAT work....I shall return...7 stars
Reviewed by mschackmuth@aol.com
mschackmuth@aol.com bought "Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns" on our website
02/15/2019 - 06:31:02 PM
Love fingers
Will you eat one, how about two, try for three, c'mon four, hey...save me some!!!I love them too you know.
Reviewed by DonnaIMetscher
DonnaIMetscher bought "Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns" on our website
02/08/2019 - 05:04:25 PM
Clothespin cookies
Delicious is the best way to describe these cookies. They remind me of Mom's cookies - buttery and sweet. Very hard to stop eating, once I start. I have sent them as gifts, but my fav is buying them for myself.
Reviewed by Susan Balden
02/08/2019 - 08:58:59 AM
Clothespin Cookies
My Mother-in- law's 90th birthday is coming up and going to serve these at her birthday get together! Really appreciate being able to purchase these delightful cookies!!!
Reviewed by srj1956
srj1956 bought "Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns" on our website
02/07/2019 - 09:09:23 PM
Delicious
Delicious , melt in your mouth..did I mention addictive?? Better buy 2, 1 for you and 1 to share . Pastry is light, filling is perfect. Definitely ordering again.
Reviewed by Nancy
12/02/2018 - 12:50:10 PM
So Fresh
Amazing how fresh the Cream Horns were and so delicious. I ordered them on Saturday and they were delivered on Wednesday fresh as if they were just made in my kitchen. What great service and products. The Kolachi was just as fresh and delicious also. Will tell all my friends, because this place deserves to be known to all that want great bakery products. Good Work Butter Maid Bakery!
Reviewed by rcycholl
rcycholl bought "Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns" on our website
11/05/2018 - 08:39:08 PM
Good, but small
I received my box of Lady Locks today and they taste good. Received them fresh. However in my entire life, I NEVER seen lady Locks so small. Reminds me of a old Wendy's commercial. Instead of asking "Where's the Beef?" its Where's the cream?" I am very disappointed in the size of the Lady Locks
Reviewed by Bebe
03/27/2018 - 06:18:52 PM
Clothespin Cookies
My two dozen cookies arrived yesterday and I've already at a dozen! They were packed very well and very, very fresh. I would definitely recommend these!
Reviewed by Mary
12/18/2017 - 12:09:02 PM
Clothespin cookies
Everyone loved them! Gone in a flash!
Reviewed by am@thenewcomers.us
am@thenewcomers.us bought "Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns" on our website
12/13/2017 - 01:24:57 AM
Lady Locks
Fantabulous!
Reviewed by Sharon Caldwell
12/06/2017 - 05:53:06 AM
Best ever
I spent my childhood summers in Boardman and a dear family friend made clothespin cookies every summer. I haven't had any in a decade. Bought 2 dozen for family gifts and they were so delicious I ate them ALL! Had to reorder
Reviewed by Rosemary Alexander
12/05/2017 - 04:55:53 PM
Clothespin cookies
These are the most delicious cookies on the face of the earth. Enough said, just buy them!
Reviewed by Joesr
Joesr bought "Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns" on our website
12/03/2017 - 03:19:45 PM
Great.
These were great. Remind me of the bear claws only much smaller
Reviewed by Judy R
12/03/2017 - 10:37:17 AM
Great, but ....
I grew up eating my mom's lady fingers. I still do. She is 90 years old and still baking. Your crust is exactly the same, but her filling is less dense. I'm sure if I had eaten yours first they would be 5 stars
Reviewed by Irma
12/01/2017 - 11:09:47 PM
Fantabulous
These were by far the best little creamy pastries ever. They are small enough to make for a very elegant presentation. Sadly, they were packaged so well none were broken, which is what I was going to use as an excuse to eat some. Oh well......
Reviewed by Robert
12/01/2017 - 03:34:24 PM
Great cream horns
I grew up with the large version of these. The are nice bite size morsels. I enjoyed them.
Reviewed by Carmela C
12/01/2017 - 05:51:32 AM
cream horns
The best ever...I served 90% of my order ... and ate the rest with a cup of coffee...Heaven
Reviewed by Lynne
11/30/2017 - 09:11:31 PM
Good but damaged during shipping
They were very tasty; but most were broken and the filling had melted. They were edible and good; but again, damaged--I had planned on taking them to our Thanksgiving party but couldn't even put them out on a serving plate because they looked so bad.
Reviewed by Rosemary Bogumil
11/29/2017 - 04:36:50 PM
Lady Locks and walnut butterballs
Sent these to my grandson in S.C.. As usual, packaging and delivery was great. He said they are awesome and very addicting. The problem is they are gone in 3 days. He said "Keep them coming Gram".
Reviewed by M Smith
11/29/2017 - 01:58:34 PM
Lady Fingers
First time ordering these. They were so good that I actually ate all of them in a day! Can't wait to get more.
Reviewed by Nancy Boynton
11/28/2017 - 05:38:36 PM
Thanksgiving
This was the first time we had these cookies and they were great!
Reviewed by Patricia Ungar
11/28/2017 - 03:17:14 PM
A warm memory
Not only did these cookies remind me of home, but I did not realize until I received them and looked at the return information that they are from Boardman. I grew up right next door in Poland! While these cookies are a little smaller than what we had as children, they were just as yummy. It is so special to have a little bit of home from Ohio here in Florida. Thank you so much.
Reviewed by Janet Baron
11/27/2017 - 07:34:56 PM
Just like ...
These lady locked reminded me of the lady locked my friends mom would make and we would fill.....just great memories. THANK YOU for bringing this memory back
Reviewed by Beaches
11/27/2017 - 06:37:46 PM
Amazing!!!
These are delicious. Just like Mom used to make! Shipped fast and in great condition - even shipped some to an APO and they got there in 7 days!
Reviewed by Shirley Todd
11/26/2017 - 07:58:50 PM
Buttercream filled cookie
I can’t keep them on hand because they keep disappearing. My husband swears he didn’t eat them but can’t explain the trail of powder surgery to his chair.
Reviewed by Linda B
11/24/2017 - 03:06:37 PM
Cream Horns
These were absolutely wonderful! Brought back so many memories. You won’t be disappointed.
Reviewed by Caroline
11/23/2017 - 11:29:17 PM
The greatest Creme Horns
All of your products deserve praise.
My son said 'these are the best'.
Flaky pastry with 'just right' creamy filling.
Can't eat 'just one'.
Reviewed by Anna
11/20/2017 - 10:05:56 PM
Outstanding mini cream horns
These mini horns just melt in your mouth. They are a great treat and vey delicious. YUM!
Reviewed by Larry in AZ
11/20/2017 - 01:51:31 PM
A taste of Home
Great little cookie. I can't find these in AZ. I have always received the items fresh just baked. Shipping items to me in AZ has never been an issue. They are packaged and shipped well, so don't worry if you need them shipped to you!
Reviewed by Pat
11/20/2017 - 01:48:02 PM
The best in the west!
No one in Texas can touch this! On a scale of 1-10, I rate Bitter Maid 11!
Reviewed by Yvonne L
11/19/2017 - 01:16:14 PM
Disappointed
Not as good as I hoped.
Reviewed by LAR
11/17/2017 - 09:02:18 PM
Truly Wonderful!
These are so fresh tasting and so delicious and not too sweet at all! The flaky pastry and creamy center is delicious. You can taste the butter they are so good. Friends came over and thought I made them them fresh they were so impressed ! I told them where they came from and they wanted to order some.
Reviewed by MaryAnn Wharton
11/16/2017 - 06:51:33 AM
Horn review
I've ordered these before. They are excellent every time! Creamy center, tasty exterior.
Reviewed by Betty
11/15/2017 - 02:33:56 PM
Best of the best!
Everything I ordered was ABSOLUTELY delicious. Reminded me of growing up in Pennsylvania (and I am old). Wonderful!!
Reviewed by Gale
11/15/2017 - 11:32:59 AM
Just Right
These cookies were light and flakey with just the right amount of filling. They were just right.
Reviewed by Jessica
11/14/2017 - 10:36:58 AM
Creme Horns/Lady Locks
The creme horns/lady locks were absolutely, positively delicious. However, they are much, much smaller than I anticipated. I am used to the larger creme horns that I had when I was a young child, many, many years ago.
Reviewed by Petra
11/07/2017 - 04:44:50 PM
Lady Locks
The cookies are delicious! Will order again!
Reviewed by Sarah
11/06/2017 - 02:45:25 PM
clothespin cookies
I was originally surprised because the cookies are alot shorter than the picture indicates. They were delicious. My only complaint was that they got hard quickly.
Reviewed by rtrr2000
rtrr2000 bought "Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns" on our website
11/06/2017 - 01:30:46 PM
Yearly Orders
I spend hundreds off dollars every year with Butter Maid. From Kolachi, Nut Horns, Kiffles, Butterballs, Clothespins, etc.
I spend the money because I don't have the time to do what my grandmother and mom use to do!!
From an Italian/Irsih family from Boardman, I learned how to do a lot!
I still make Pizelles and most of our traditions.
However, after leaving Boardman, death of all my family and moving to Columbus 34 years ago, I rely on Butter Maid to help me keep my family's past alive.
When I bring out the treats my grandmother and mother use to do at the holiday's from Butter Maid, the family talks and memories open up, with many tears and laughter!
I don't care about cost, just good family memories!
Thank you Butter Maid!

Reviewed by SisterB49
SisterB49 bought "Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns" on our website
11/03/2017 - 05:31:01 PM
Lady Fingers-Cream Horns
This is the first time I have ordered the Lady Fingers-Cream Horns and I absolutely LOVED them. We ate them so fast I will definitely need to order more. What a shame LOL.
Reviewed by rtrr2000
rtrr2000 bought "Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns" on our website
11/02/2017 - 08:35:09 PM
Mom
I grew up in Boardman! I was born in 1960, and grew up with my family making everything Buttermaid makes!
I moved away in 1985, to begin my career as a teacher.
Mom used to be able to bake. After, many years , I took over the baking in Columbus. Then, Buttermaid! All of our favorite holiday cookies, Kolachi, etc.
No more questions! I spend hundreds, probably, thousands, to keep our family traditions alive.
It's ok! Now if they made pizzelles!
I only bake Mom's chocolate chip cookies and pizzelles, Buttermaid does the rest.
Worth it...YES!
There aren't many of us left, but the traditions are still carried out!
We appreciate Buttermaid!
God Bless and continue the traditions!!
The Talley Family!
Reviewed by Mary Anne
10/24/2017 - 09:19:45 AM
Wonderful!
These are absolutely the best. Everything I've ordered from you has been raved about by my family. Thank you for your easy ordering system and for giving me the chance to give back to our troops!
Reviewed by Mary Trimble
10/23/2017 - 04:23:19 PM
Out of Town Delivry
I ordered for my family in West Virginia. It came to them fresh and fast and I will order again,they loved them very much
Reviewed by Bzy Lady
10/20/2017 - 01:46:40 PM
Clothespin Cookies
They arrived in perfect condition. I have frozen them till Thanksgiving. So, so far so good.
Reviewed by Barb Hooten
10/15/2017 - 07:27:12 PM
Lady Fingers
I was disappointed in the cookies. The dough was not light and flakey. I would not purchase again.
Reviewed by Laura
10/11/2017 - 06:05:50 PM
Whoa!!!!
Absolutely delicious. I was worried they would arrive in crumbs since their are a delicate cookie. But the packaging protected every last one of them. Not a single cracked or broken cookie. Of course they didn't last long because they are so good. I can't say enough good thing about your company - from the ordering on the website to the prompt delivery to the wonderfully delicious cookies - everything was superb.
Reviewed by Dsbarens
Dsbarens bought "Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns" on our website
10/08/2017 - 08:22:58 PM
Buttery and delicious
Great cookies, everything we ordered, fresh and great tasting! Thanks!!!
Reviewed by HLouise
09/22/2017 - 11:44:21 AM
Yummy!!
These are my husbands favorite cookie. I had to freeze them cause he would have finished every last one!! As for myself, I love everything from Butter Maid! Thanks you so much for such wonderful baked goods from scratch.
Reviewed by Patricia Hall
09/19/2017 - 10:59:44 AM
Cream Horns
I ordered the mini cream horns for my niece's wedding. We did an Italian sweet table. The table was beautiful. I couldn't find any bakery around here to make them for me so I found your bakery on the internet. I never ordered from you before but I certainly will again. They were delicious. Thank You!
Reviewed by Carol
09/12/2017 - 01:31:24 PM
Clothespin cookies
Awesome! Had to pace ourselves or we would have eaten them all in one sitting.
Reviewed by lemmonannamarie@yahoo.co
lemmonannamarie@yahoo.co bought "Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns" on our website
09/08/2017 - 11:22:13 AM
Lady Locks
Delicious!
Reviewed by Tamee
09/07/2017 - 10:17:40 AM
Heavenly
The Lady Locks are heavenly almost like my Mother-in-law's. I remember stuff the pasties with the filling. they were the best with coffee. Since she is gone and I never mastered the dough for these, I will order again. My husband like the also.
Reviewed by Bela
08/29/2017 - 07:46:00 PM
Clothespin cookies
This was the 1st time I tried these cookies and all I could say is WOW! They were far better than I expected and I don't usually say that about anything. Everyone must try these cookies, they are fresh and taste GREAT!
Reviewed by Mary Anne Smith
08/17/2017 - 10:09:14 PM
Extrodinary!!
If this doesn't melt in your mouth try another! That's my excuse for eating more than one. These were my favorites during the Christmas holidays back home in Hermitage, PA. We'd get boxes of them and while mom wasn't looking, sneak one or two. That's still how I feel about these - no one can eat just one!!
Reviewed by bgolaski
bgolaski bought "Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns" on our website
08/14/2017 - 05:32:11 PM
Reviews by Barbara
The were wonderful. Saving some for a Tea with friends.
Reviewed by msmittzie
08/11/2017 - 01:46:26 PM
Sooo.. very delicious!
Watched my daughter taste one of these when they arrived. Her eyes lit up and she said, "Oh, my gosh, I can't believe how delicious these are!" She was right! They are to 'die' for!! Thanks for making such great products and having them arrive so very fresh!!
Reviewed by Margaret
08/06/2017 - 10:17:42 PM
Clothespin Cookies
They were wonderful. To bad they did not last very long.
Reviewed by pianoplayer
pianoplayer bought "Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns" on our website
08/04/2017 - 06:33:17 PM
Just like mama made
I can remember my Hungarian mother spending hours in the kitchen throughout the holidays baking nut rolls, tassies and what we called cream filled clothespin cookies. These were about as close to my mother's as I have found. The container with the 2 dozen cookies did not last 24 hours around here. Loved them.
Reviewed by David
08/03/2017 - 07:24:31 PM
ATLANTA, GA
They were good! Not my favorite - but good!
Reviewed by marilyn
07/31/2017 - 03:24:04 PM
clothespins cookies
these are wonderful and my grandmother made them
Reviewed by Eileen
07/29/2017 - 12:50:06 PM
Wedding cookies
I ordered cookies for my niece's wedding. They were wonderful! Enjoyed by all and none were left over. Thank you for providing the classic cookies we grew up enjoying at weddings in western Pennsylvania.
Reviewed by tim
04/14/2017 - 09:50:40 AM
kolachi
these are melt in your mouth delicious
order several, I went thru the first dozen in minutes
Reviewed by Dawn Veraldo
11/20/2016 - 02:04:33 PM
Wonderful memories
I'm a Youngstown native, so I grew up with my grandmother making amazing things like kolache & clothes pin cookies - I was thrilled to find Butter Maid Bakery so now I can order these delicious things online and the "love" is delivered right to my door here in Washington state. I'm a long way from home, but these baked goods bring back wonderful memories that I can now share with my son (they are great story starters ;). Thank you Butter Maid Bakery and it's employees who are keeping the nostalgia alive and well across the US!
Reviewed by Kim Ferrero
11/13/2016 - 12:50:34 PM
Oh. My. Goodness.
I ordered the Kolachi last year for Christmas. DELICIOUS! So came back this year to do the same. Also decided to try the Clothespin Cookies since I'm responsible for a Thanksgiving dessert at the husband's family. WELL GOSH DARN IT! I've got to order ANOTHER round because when my first order arrived, I figured I better try them first. OH. MY. GOODNESS. They are Heaven. Ate them all. BEWARE people... these things are amazing!
Reviewed by RitaBear
RitaBear bought "Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns" on our website
09/04/2016 - 11:27:07 AM
Soooooo good!
This was one of the first things I tasted on my first order...and knew I'd be a Buttermaid Bakery customer for life! These are so amazing, and so much better than grocery store mass-produced. And Buttermaid's customer service is just astounding. Friendly, thoughtful "welcomes" -- even a notecard from everyone welcoming me as a customer. I also got the peanut butter cookies and loved them too. What a wonderful company with wonderful food. I couldn't recommend them more sincerely.
Reviewed by Customer_Testimonials
03/30/2016 - 07:00:42 PM
THE BEST
THE "CLOTHESPIN" COOKIES ARE THE BEST I HAVE EVER HAD. IT ONLY TOOK ME ABOUT AN HOUR TO CONSUME MOST OF THEM. SHARED A LITTLE WITH HUBBY. I HAVE SEARCHED FOR YEARS TO LOCATE THESE COOKIES. AND I HIT THE JACKPOT! I HIGHLY RECOMMEND THESE. AS WELL, THEIR CUSTOMER SERVICE CARRIES JUST AS MUCH QUALITY AS THE COOKIES. - MARY FLORY, HAMPTON, GA
Reviewed by Customer_Testimonials
03/12/2016 - 03:45:34 PM
Delicious
WOW! Am I a happy camper--yes! The "clothespin" cookies I have searched for is complete. These are the most delicious clothespin cookies I have ever eaten! I promise this is so. Quality, fresh, tasty filling--they are outrageously scrumptious. The packaging is lovely with an enclosed hand-written thank you note. Next I want a nut roll & poppy seed roll. Can't wait until I get my SS check. Thank You God for for allowing me to enjoy these special sweets in my golden years. God bless America for the freedom for us to be able to buy food w/o it being governed by the government. Mary Flory, Hampton, GA
Reviewed by Customer_Testimonials
02/07/2016 - 04:30:23 PM
So happy
I wanted to let you know that my father just loved your products!! It made me so happy. Nothing was broken. I may have to give up making ladylocks myself!! Thanks again. So very pleased. - Faith Plutto, Hamilton, NJ
Reviewed by Customer_Testimonials
11/15/2015 - 05:30:54 PM
Delicious
We got our cookies today- delicious clothespins! My husband says the nut roll reminds him of grandma! Thank you for all the care you put in every package. - Tami Harpole, Billings, MT
Reviewed by Customer_Emails
04/14/2015 - 11:10:23 AM
So happy
Dear Butter Maid Bakery,

Thank you for the delicious cookies! They arrived quickly and PERFECTLY! None of them were crushed or broken (until they went into my mouth LOL!!) My family was so happy with them! Everyone LOVED them!
Luann S - Orchard park, NY
Reviewed by Customer_Testimonials
11/16/2014 - 07:40:58 PM
Love The Goodies
I placed an order back a month ago, for 1 of my oldest friends. Our children went through 12 years of school and we still remain friends. After the passing of her Husband, I sent her 2 packs of Kiffles and Lady Fingers. I don't believe in flowers. These sweets helped her get through 1 day with a cup of warm tea. She still has more in the freezer. LOVE THE GOODIES FROM BUTTER MAID.
Linda Willem, Homestead, Florida
Reviewed by kyuchak
kyuchak bought "Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns" on our website
12/07/2013 - 09:47:22 AM
Best Ever
The service, packaging and shipping were supreme. Not a crumb out of place when it arrived in Maryland.

Light, creamy goodness. Mother made these at Christmas time decades ago. They took tons of time and patience to make. So nice to find these confections at a reasonable price, available for shipping, and just as delicious as Mom made them.

I will be purchasing these for others and self in the future.
Reviewed by depotdude
depotdude bought "Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns" on our website
04/26/2012 - 01:37:36 PM
"MELT IN YOUR MOUTH"
These cookies are fantastic! They literally melt in your mouth. So light and airy, yet full of flavor. Since I live in Florida, I'd like to freeze some to have for later but there gone before I can put any in the freezer. Try These! You won't be disappointed!
Reviewed by tracikg
03/12/2012 - 12:11:55 PM
To die for!
We love 'Lady fingers'! When we drive to pennsylvania from Utah, we always bring a cooler, so we can bring boxes of lady fingers home to savor, they freeze really well, and taste just as good! We've never been able to find them anywhere in the country like they make them at Buttermaid Bakery.
Our Customers Say...

I bought these as a Christmas present for my husband and me. We didn't wait for Christmas to open one though. What a wonderful surprise to find out they are just like my mother use to make. She was given the recipe from her mother-in-law who came to the U.S. from Croatia. She's been gone 20 yrs. now and to taste these nut rolls brought back ...
Read More>>
So far I have order the nut and the nut and raisin kolachi. Also the apricot cookies and the cream stuffed rolls. All were excellant in taste and quality. I look forward to ordering more of everything you make. Keep up the good work. John Mihoc PS the cookies and Kolachi tasted just like what I used to get from my relatives during ...
Read More>>
My sister sent us three kolachi's from Butter Maid Bakery in Ohio with the okay to break into them before Christmas. Even though she said these were the best bakery-made kolachi's she's had, I had my doubts when I cut into the nut roll because I grew up with excellent Hungarian bakers who made the best nut and poppyseed rolls. OMG - they're ...
Read More>>