Peanut Butter Buckeyes

Peanut Butter Buckeyes Box - Buckeye Candy
Click to enlarge

More images

Click to enlarge


Retail Price: $24.00
Sale Price: $20.99
Product ID : buckeyes
12 oz Box, 8 Buckeyes

Add To Wish List


Buckeyes are a super delicious peanut butter fudge ball covered in chocolate.  Also called a buckeye candy, these highly addicting buckeyes are very popular in our state of Ohio, where they were named after the state tree, the Ohio Buckeye tree. Here in Youngstown, Ohio these addicting buckeyes appear right alongside the kolachi cookies and large kolachi rolls on every Wedding Cookie Table.  No machine produced factory candy here, these are all handmade with simple ingredients!

Size: Handmade buckeyes vary in size & weight. They're large in comparison to others we've tried at about 1.5oz each, 8 per roughly 12 oz box.

PLEASE NOTE: Buckeyes may become soft during transit if you are shipping to a warm climate. If exposed to heat, the chocolate & peanut butter fudge can lose shape.  Neither will affect the quality, simply refrigerate or freeze to make firm again.  Small pieces of chocolate can crack off the peanut butter balls during transit in any temperature.

The ingredients in our buckeyes do not contain gluten, however we are not a gluten free bakery and therefore cross contamination is possible. 


Product Reviews

Reviewed by Debra Stadler
03/31/2020 - 05:24:42 PM
First time buying these too sweet for me and my family. And need more chocolate coating on them would be good if little snaller
Reviewed by Peggy Eidman
03/28/2020 - 06:18:35 AM
fabulous buckeyes
These candies are the best I have ever tasted. They are so rich and creamy. The chocolate is great but the peanut butter filling is amazing. If you have never had these you must order them today! Thanks!
Reviewed by Buckeyes WOW
03/25/2020 - 04:40:56 PM
A must have for our home
We are Ohio State Buckeye fans so these Buckeye cookies are the bomb! Love them! So big to. You can actually share one with someone. I know we will be ordering more in the future. :)
Reviewed by Tammy
03/10/2020 - 02:31:01 PM
Sister loved the buckeyes
I'm from the buckeye state and had to send these to my sister who now lives in Florida. She really liked them. Saves making them from scratch yourself. The only problem is, there aren't enough of them!
Reviewed by Nancy Fitzgerald
01/15/2020 - 01:05:09 PM
Delicious buckeyes
I ordered them previously for myself. They are my sister's favorite so I ordered them for her birthday--I think she will be surprised and enjoy them when she gets them today.
Reviewed by Diane
01/08/2020 - 07:57:49 PM
Oh my goodness! Such great flavor! These were much larger than I’m used to. I could only eat one at a sitting. I was also able to share one and still had plenty of flavor for myself! Yum!
Reviewed by Nancy Fitzgerald
01/04/2020 - 03:46:34 PM
delicious buckeyes
Sooooo good. I always loved these cookies but had a hard time finding any. My sister tried to make them but was not very successful. She has a birthday soon so I ordered some for her birthday (she just loves them--these are her favorite cookie). She will be so surprised. I will order them again sometime for myself!
Reviewed by Linda Hazelbaker
01/02/2020 - 12:21:57 PM
Delicious !!!
Reviewed by Barb Medzie
01/01/2020 - 11:30:11 PM
Well enjoyed!
Reviewed by Gyneth James
01/01/2020 - 01:32:31 PM
Peanut Butter balls
I found these a bit too sweet,but my gluten-free son enjoyed every bite!
Reviewed by jennifer.gligonic@3ccomp
jennifer.gligonic@3ccomp bought "Peanut Butter Buckeyes" on our website
12/29/2019 - 11:38:53 PM
Just Ok
Just OK. Quite expensive for 8 buckeyes. In fairness, the large size could easily be cut in half for 16. Okay - but nothing extraordinary
Reviewed by Virginia
12/29/2019 - 02:25:31 PM
Disappointed that only eight. Need make them smaller no o e wants a giant chunk of peanut butter. Would not but again not worth money.
Reviewed by Ed McIntyre
12/26/2019 - 09:45:16 AM
Not as good as in prior years. I won't be ordering them again. Plus, you are pricing yourself out of my range. I did enjoy the kolache's though.
Reviewed by Cookie
12/25/2019 - 05:02:38 PM
Best tasting buckeyes just like my mother-in-law use to make for the holidays!
Reviewed by Malvina Kumar
12/23/2019 - 02:19:32 AM
Who doesn't love peanut butter and chocolate?! I'm a huge fan of this pairing. Love - love - love - love it!!!!!!!
Reviewed by Lori
12/23/2019 - 12:41:50 AM
These were definitely good, great taste/ consistency.
I think they need to be smaller/bite size? They are pretty and shouldn't need to be cut in half for entertaining.
Reviewed by Mj
12/21/2019 - 04:17:25 PM
1st time ordering and had to reorder!
A delicious enchantment for one's tastebuds!
Reviewed by Diane
12/19/2019 - 09:58:52 PM
I just adore the creamy flavor. You can taste the quality in each buckeye! Doesn’t get any better than these!
Reviewed by Kathy
12/18/2019 - 04:46:18 PM
We are from Ohio and brings back so many good memories. Amazing what a cookie can do to brighten your spirits.
Reviewed by mazurbeam
mazurbeam bought "Peanut Butter Buckeyes" on our website
11/24/2019 - 01:30:27 PM
Good sized! Taste great.
Reviewed by Girr Gertrude
11/21/2019 - 10:31:08 PM
Sweet Treat
I have nothing new to add to the buckeye reviews: these are fantastic treats.
I do have a suggestion; a variety pack. I would like to sample before I commit.
Reviewed by Linda
11/18/2019 - 07:24:24 PM
These are the most delicious buckeyes that I have ever tasted.
Reviewed by Margaret Patti
11/16/2019 - 07:46:23 PM
Very good !!!!!! And froze well too. I might have to move to Ohio if you stop making these !
Reviewed by Dave
11/13/2019 - 02:06:39 PM
Wanted to share!
I wanted to share, but family ate them up too darn quick!
Reviewed by Theresa Rauschenberg
11/09/2019 - 11:23:18 AM
Delicious had to put them in the freezer so we couldn't
eat them all at once!
Reviewed by bought "Peanut Butter Buckeyes" on our website
11/05/2019 - 07:59:06 PM
They are truly perfect. Love them
Reviewed by Bo Zdanowicz
11/04/2019 - 07:16:08 PM
My Grandson said they were amazing. Send More Please.
Reviewed by clp128
clp128 bought "Peanut Butter Buckeyes" on our website
10/16/2019 - 03:43:01 PM
These are delicious! Generous size & tastes like best homemade I’ve ever had!
Reviewed by Lisa
09/28/2019 - 10:04:59 AM
Best thing ever
These are delicious and are hard to keep around. The day we received the order 1/2 was eaten that evening. They are the best things I have ever eaten.
Reviewed by Pete Striley
09/21/2019 - 03:24:52 AM
Great eats
I just love these buckeyes!
Reviewed by Jim
08/09/2019 - 06:39:21 PM
Love them.
Reviewed by elizabeth scheide
07/23/2019 - 08:10:06 PM
These are blissful. Heaven sent. I shall be ordering more when they are gone. Thanks for the delight.
Reviewed by Kim K. Harvilla
05/23/2019 - 01:33:40 PM
These are fantastic - just as I remember from my childhood.
Reviewed by Darlene
05/18/2019 - 12:15:20 AM
These were tasty but alot. Had to cut them into smaller bite size pieces as 1/4 of it was more then plenty.
Reviewed by chick
05/10/2019 - 12:19:33 AM
miss these
we used to live in ohio...miss buckeyes...these are huge!!
Reviewed by Barbara Huber
05/01/2019 - 09:26:53 PM
These took me back home!
These are the buckeyes that I remember from my childhood in Southwestern Pennsylvania, and one bite had me traveling back there in spirit for Easter. Amazing taste, texture and quality. I will definitely be
ordering again!
Reviewed by Sue Hamm
04/30/2019 - 08:46:36 PM
Beyond delicious!!!!!
Reviewed by Kathleen B
04/29/2019 - 07:57:51 PM
First time ordering from you and wanted something a little special for our anniversary 'dessert'. We are both huge peanut butter and chocolate fans and we weren't disappointed! We can't wait to try some of your other products and we'll be ordering again soon...
Reviewed by Judy
04/29/2019 - 12:34:02 PM
Peanut butter buckeye
They were very good would like more chocolate and a little pricy
Reviewed by bought "Peanut Butter Buckeyes" on our website
04/29/2019 - 01:49:48 AM
The peanut butter/choc treats were excellent. I also was told they are Kosher, whereas your Kolachi rolls are not...something about leavened bread
Delivery was exceptional fast.
Reviewed by Pam
04/26/2019 - 09:19:34 AM
very good. not too sweet, not over-powering peanut butter either. yum!
Reviewed by Virginia Trusty
04/23/2019 - 10:14:38 AM
peanut butter
too big, was surprised at how few there were and did not like taste. my buckeyes taste more peanutbutter
Reviewed by Linda M Browne
04/21/2019 - 08:13:10 PM
Needs a Complete Chocolate Covering!!!
Perfection if covered completely with chocolate.....What's up with the lack of chocolate....someone not able to cover a ball?
Reviewed by Monika Gregory
04/21/2019 - 12:58:57 PM
Heaven in a bite
These buckeyes were the best ones I have ever tasted. I don't even like peanut butter all that much but those tasted hevanly.
Reviewed by BA KYE
04/17/2019 - 05:50:05 PM
Reviewed by Barbaraeredbbq
04/16/2019 - 10:17:11 PM
Wish I Ordered More
These are AMAZING. I tried one when they arrived and wanted to eat them at the same time. Had to put them in the freezer to keep me from eating them before the dinner party on the 20th for Easter.
Reviewed by bought "Peanut Butter Buckeyes" on our website
04/15/2019 - 11:24:54 PM
Peanut Butter Buckeyes
This is my first time trying these candies. They were very good and huge in size. I think I would have preferred more and smaller pieces. Not sure I would get these again will probably try some of the other cookies first
Reviewed by
04/15/2019 - 11:07:50 AM
Peanut butter and chocolate - what could go wrong?? These were awesome, wicked good!
Reviewed by Lori Gleason
04/12/2019 - 01:13:15 PM
My father in law used to make these when he was younger and LOVED them.
Reviewed by bought "Peanut Butter Buckeyes" on our website
04/10/2019 - 09:00:34 PM
Such a Treat!
Just Wonderful! Peanut Butter and Chocolate, Who could or would complain? Very Good! Spectacular! Totally Awesome! Beyond Compare! Loved by ALL.
Reviewed by bought "Peanut Butter Buckeyes" on our website
04/10/2019 - 08:56:50 PM
Number 1 Treat from Ohio
My darling husband, from Salem Ohio, claims only Buckeyes can eat these legally, NOT TRUE! Get some and try them and you'll see why he was so anxious to take the delivery of these delectable darlings!
Reviewed by Ruth
04/07/2019 - 04:35:37 PM
So good!
These were a gift for my husband for his birthday! So rich & peanut butter creamy! Really, really good!
02/28/2019 - 01:25:14 PM
Those buckeyes are out of this world. It is difficult not to overeat them. Wow. Thanks for a sumptuous candy.
Reviewed by Shannon
02/21/2019 - 02:42:16 PM
OMG Buckeyes are amazing!
I ordered these as a treat for my husband. He is from Ohio but had never had these before. All I can say is he was soooo happy when he ate the first one! He totally loved them, said they were the best thing ever! I tried a bite and I concur with him, they are delicious!
Reviewed by paj
02/10/2019 - 04:20:48 PM
Buckeyes are the best thing ever!!!!
Reviewed by Mary Kay Charbonneau
02/08/2019 - 05:38:36 PM
Buck eyes
This is the BEST bakery ever. I have ordered many things. I send a lot to my friends when free shipping. I recommend this place highly, everything so delicious. I will always order from this bakeet.
Reviewed by sdeli
01/13/2019 - 05:08:05 PM
I have ordered from Buttermaid for several years now and everyone expects the nut rolls and Italian cookies.
Reviewed by Donna
08/26/2018 - 01:19:40 PM
very good
These buckeyes were very good. I did order them during very warm weather. When I received them, they were starting to melt. I put them in the fridge right away. They were fine after that, but when shipped, they should be packed in dry ice.
Reviewed by Sharon
12/06/2017 - 06:01:11 AM
Best ever
These buckeyes brought us back to our childhood. Best ever! Ordered more for gifts. Smooth, creamy, full of flavor and addicting
Reviewed by Cindy
12/03/2017 - 11:13:49 AM
These were a big hit! Loved by all.
Reviewed by Denise
12/02/2017 - 06:54:30 PM
too much sugar mixed in with the peanutbutter
Too much sugar mixed in with the peanut butter for my liking. Great size though
Reviewed by Marian
11/27/2017 - 09:06:23 AM
These are addicting!!! Eat one, then eat them all. They are so good!!!
Reviewed by p christina
11/10/2017 - 03:50:54 PM
notmally these are good
in the past when i have received these. the chocolate was smoothe. this order, however, the outside was gritty.
Reviewed by Anne
10/15/2017 - 05:06:27 PM
Buckeye Peanut Butter Balls
These peanut butter balls are awesome!
Reviewed by Dsbarens
09/27/2017 - 05:22:19 PM
Wonderful! Just like mom used to bake
So tasty and buttery! Tried for first time, willmorder more for the holidays! Glad I found your shop online, shipped to Cali, we love your bakery!!
Reviewed by bought "Peanut Butter Buckeyes" on our website
09/08/2017 - 11:23:38 AM
Reviewed by Maureen
08/17/2017 - 09:52:50 AM
Delicious Kolachi
Loved the walnut and the poppyseed. Best we ever had. Am ordering these again. Will try buckeyes when the weather is cooler, afraid they will melt on their way to NC!
Reviewed by Pat
08/06/2017 - 12:04:31 PM
The best
These are as good as my grandma used to make and my daughter agrees.
Reviewed by Susan S
08/02/2017 - 11:00:07 AM
The peanut butter buckeyes are simply heaven in every bite!
Reviewed by Richard L
05/02/2017 - 01:43:46 PM
Love them
The peanut butter buckeyes are so good!
Reviewed by Mary Pat McDonald
02/25/2017 - 04:23:25 PM
Received an order this week of kolachi, clothespin cookies, kieflis and buckeyes...WOW......Everything is absolutely delicious! I am so happy I took the chance and ordered from you. I read a review that was positive and thought it would be a nice Valentine treat for my family. Will definitely order from you again!
Our Customers Say...

A huge thank you from Afghanistan for the cookies sent out to me via Soldiers Angels. Our engineer shop of Army and Air Force personnel quickly devoured them. I'm originally from Ohio so it was nice to see something from my home state, too.
Read More>>
Just wanted you to know that the walnut kolachke was delicious...tasted just like my grandmother used to make. I haven't had one in years, and I'm so delighted to have found you.
Read More>>
Thank you so much for your prompt delivery of cookies to our son. They arrived in Germany on his birthday! He said they were delicious! It was his first birthday away from home and I was so glad they got there on his special day. I think he even shared a few with his soldier buddies! Next time I'll have to send more!
Read More>>