Peanut Butter Buckeyes

Peanut Butter Buckeyes Box - Buckeye Candy
Click to enlarge

More images

Click to enlarge

Purchase

Retail Price: $24.00
Sale Price: $17.99
Product ID : buckeyes
12 oz Box, 8 Buckeyes


Add To Wish List


Description

Buckeyes are a super delicious peanut butter fudge ball covered in chocolate.  Also called a buckeye candy, these highly addicting buckeyes are very popular in our state of Ohio, where they were named after the state tree, the Ohio Buckeye tree. Here in Youngstown, Ohio these addicting buckeyes appear right alongside the kolachi cookies and large kolachi rolls on every Wedding Cookie Table.  No machine produced factory candy here, these are all handmade with simple ingredients!

Size: Handmade buckeyes vary in size & weight. They're large in comparison to others we've tried at about 1.5oz each, 8 per roughly 12 oz box.

PLEASE NOTE: Buckeyes may become soft during transit if you are shipping to a warm climate. If exposed to heat, the chocolate & peanut butter fudge can lose shape.  Neither will affect the quality, simply refrigerate or freeze to make firm again.  Small pieces of chocolate can crack off the peanut butter balls during transit in any temperature.

The ingredients in our buckeyes do not contain gluten, however we are not a gluten free bakery and therefore cross contamination is possible. 

INGREDIENTS: PURE CANE POWDERED CONFECTIONERS SUGAR (CANE SUGAR, CORNSTARCH), COCOA CONFECTIONERY WAFERS (SUGAR, PARTIALLY HYDROGENATED PALM KERNEL AND COTTONSEED OILS, NONFAT DRY MILK, COCOA, MILK, GLYCERYL LACTO ESTERS OF FATTY ACIDS, SOY LECITHIN, AND SALT), PEANUT BUTTER, BUTTER.

Product Reviews

Reviewed by paj
02/10/2019 - 04:20:48 PM
OMG
Buckeyes are the best thing ever!!!!
Reviewed by Mary Kay Charbonneau
02/08/2019 - 05:38:36 PM
Buck eyes
This is the BEST bakery ever. I have ordered many things. I send a lot to my friends when free shipping. I recommend this place highly, everything so delicious. I will always order from this bakeet.
Reviewed by sdeli
01/13/2019 - 05:08:05 PM
Awesome!
I have ordered from Buttermaid for several years now and everyone expects the nut rolls and Italian cookies.
Reviewed by Donna
08/26/2018 - 01:19:40 PM
very good
These buckeyes were very good. I did order them during very warm weather. When I received them, they were starting to melt. I put them in the fridge right away. They were fine after that, but when shipped, they should be packed in dry ice.
Reviewed by Sharon
12/06/2017 - 06:01:11 AM
Best ever
These buckeyes brought us back to our childhood. Best ever! Ordered more for gifts. Smooth, creamy, full of flavor and addicting
Reviewed by Cindy
12/03/2017 - 11:13:49 AM
Buckeyes
These were a big hit! Loved by all.
Reviewed by Denise
12/02/2017 - 06:54:30 PM
too much sugar mixed in with the peanutbutter
Too much sugar mixed in with the peanut butter for my liking. Great size though
Reviewed by Marian
11/27/2017 - 09:06:23 AM
wonderful
These are addicting!!! Eat one, then eat them all. They are so good!!!
Reviewed by p christina
11/10/2017 - 03:50:54 PM
notmally these are good
in the past when i have received these. the chocolate was smoothe. this order, however, the outside was gritty.
Reviewed by Anne
10/15/2017 - 05:06:27 PM
Buckeye Peanut Butter Balls
These peanut butter balls are awesome!
Reviewed by Dsbarens
09/27/2017 - 05:22:19 PM
Wonderful! Just like mom used to bake
So tasty and buttery! Tried for first time, willmorder more for the holidays! Glad I found your shop online, shipped to Cali, we love your bakery!!
Reviewed by lemmonannamarie@yahoo.co
lemmonannamarie@yahoo.co bought "Peanut Butter Buckeyes" on our website
09/08/2017 - 11:23:38 AM
Buckeyes
Fantastic!
Reviewed by Maureen
08/17/2017 - 09:52:50 AM
Delicious Kolachi
Loved the walnut and the poppyseed. Best we ever had. Am ordering these again. Will try buckeyes when the weather is cooler, afraid they will melt on their way to NC!
Reviewed by Pat
08/06/2017 - 12:04:31 PM
The best
These are as good as my grandma used to make and my daughter agrees.
Reviewed by Susan S
08/02/2017 - 11:00:07 AM
Heavenly
The peanut butter buckeyes are simply heaven in every bite!
Reviewed by Richard L
05/02/2017 - 01:43:46 PM
Love them
The peanut butter buckeyes are so good!
Reviewed by Mary Pat McDonald
02/25/2017 - 04:23:25 PM
WOW
Received an order this week of kolachi, clothespin cookies, kieflis and buckeyes...WOW......Everything is absolutely delicious! I am so happy I took the chance and ordered from you. I read a review that was positive and thought it would be a nice Valentine treat for my family. Will definitely order from you again!
Our Customers Say...

The nut rolls sent to me via my Cousin for my birthday. I have to say it takes us back to many a early morning in grandmoms house eastcoast 4-5 am (early for youngsters) the smell of bread baking the warm oven. Coming downstairs to "help" grandmom, and don't you know there were dozens already made. I watched how she spread the dough so ...
Read More>>
Ordered for my husband birthday. He said it tasted just like his mother made. He ate 2 slices and said he could have another but would restrain himself.
Read More>>
I ordered nut rolls & cookies for the first time Christmas 2017 based on all the reviews. WHAT A HIT they were on Christmas Day. EVERY ONE commented how they reminded them of their childhood. My part of NJ doesn't have too many bakeries any more since all the groceries stores sell bakery items. At one time we had a bakery for all Eastern ...
Read More>>