Pecan Tarts aka Tassies, Caramel Cups, Pies

Homemade Pecan Tarts, Tassies, Caramel Cups, Pies
Click to enlarge


Retail Price: $28.00
Sale Price: $19.99
Product ID : pecan-tarts-tassies-cups
1 Dozen

Add To Wish List


Call them what you like... pecan tarts, tassies, caramel cups.  The buttery crust of this mini pecan pie is filled with rich & creamy caramel, topped with fresh crushed & toasted pecans. They're great at room temp, but try them warmed with coffee. This is a classic wedding cookie here in Youngstown, Ohio where they always appear next to the best selling kolachi cookies and large kolachi rolls for every special occasion.

Size: Cookies are made by hand and therefore vary in size & weight, approximately 11 oz per box.

We don't believe in preservatives, but for your safety they're required in this item. They remain the highest quality, fresh crushed pecans, no fillers, and full of the same buttery, rich & creamy caramel flavor we love.


Free shipping, coupon codes, and quantity discounts, if offered, are valid per order of all items shipped to the same address. Quantity discounts not valid by phone.

Product Reviews

Reviewed by Margaret Viands
09/16/2019 - 05:54:45 PM
Need to add more stars
If I could give these cookies 10 stars I would. Wonderful taste.
Reviewed by pdq29dbs
pdq29dbs bought "Pecan Tarts aka Tassies, Caramel Cups, Pies" on our website
07/22/2019 - 11:36:39 PM
Pecan Tarts
I made these from scratch for many years and they were exceptional! Yours taste just like mine, which are amazing! Definitely will be ordering again!
Reviewed by Denise Gibson
07/17/2019 - 01:50:32 PM
My Fav
These are my favorite cookie
Reviewed by David Quinn
06/23/2019 - 02:32:21 PM
Great tarts
It is my favorite thing, great flavor
Reviewed by Christy
05/25/2019 - 05:16:36 PM
Loved all the items I ordered, my whole family was licking their lips! The packaging was perfect and arrived sooner than I expected. Will definitely be ordering again and again!
Reviewed by PatGLex
PatGLex bought "Pecan Tarts aka Tassies, Caramel Cups, Pies" on our website
05/22/2019 - 09:49:19 AM
Just like Mom used to make
My mom hasn't made these in years -- like at least 10. I really missed having them during the holidays. So it was a delight to find out that your recipe is just like Mom's! I'll be ordering again in the future.
Reviewed by bought "Pecan Tarts aka Tassies, Caramel Cups, Pies" on our website
05/15/2019 - 05:17:01 PM
Pecan Tarts
Yummy! Like baby pecan pies. I keep them in the freezer and take out a few at a time otherwise I can eat the whole box.
Reviewed by Eleanor H.
05/07/2019 - 05:09:13 PM
Pecan Tassies
The pastry had no color to it (I expected a golden brown) and it and the filling were bland. I was so disappointed.
Reviewed by Pat
05/04/2019 - 10:24:12 PM
Pecan tasdies
Delicious! Moist and I could have ate all in one sitting.not too sweet but great taste.
Reviewed by Judy
04/29/2019 - 12:32:20 PM
Pecan Tarts
This was my least favorite of my order.... just bland
Reviewed by Nora Diaz
04/29/2019 - 10:45:44 AM
As Good As Making Them Yourself
I wanted to take some desserts common to my PA family for the rehearsal dinner when my nephew got married in NC. I didn’t, however, want the stress of baking prior to the long road trip. I’m so glad I found your site. The nut tassies arrived fast and were a hit. I even stuck them in the freezer for about 5 days prior (because I was an eager orderer and got them sooner than I needed to.). Delicious and definitely have that made with live taste! Would reorder this- and try other items- in the future!
Reviewed by Wanda
04/25/2019 - 10:51:17 PM
Oh my!
I gave these to a friend and they said better than most pies they have had!
Reviewed by Penny Winkle
04/23/2019 - 10:27:46 PM
Delicious and special year round
I was so happy to learn that I could get fabulous kolachi and cookies year round. The website was easy to navigate. Everything arrived fresh and just as expected. This will be my go to bakery from now on.
Reviewed by LuAnn
04/22/2019 - 11:39:53 AM
Delicious treats
I ordered these with some nut rolls and they were the big hit. I could eat them all day and even my nephew who does not like pecans, ate quite a few, because they were so delicious.
Reviewed by Deb Pape
04/20/2019 - 10:10:47 PM
Wonderful...just like mom used to make. I ate 5 right off the bat.
Reviewed by Barbara
04/16/2019 - 10:21:14 PM
Pecan Pie has always been my favorite, since my childhood. In High School, after classes we would go to the nearby little corner store where the little ones were sold. These take me back to those days. You have to have them!!!
Reviewed by Marge G
04/15/2019 - 01:06:58 PM
Pecan tassies
Yummy taste like pecan pie
Reviewed by timkoch
timkoch bought "Pecan Tarts aka Tassies, Caramel Cups, Pies" on our website
04/14/2019 - 02:52:32 PM
Pecan Tarts
These are just ok. They could have more taste, both in the filling and the shell. My mom's recipe was better. I would not order more of these.
Reviewed by annette11758
04/14/2019 - 09:26:27 AM
pecan tassies
I loved the taste of these little tassies but I almost cracked a tooth on a hard sharp pc of pecan or shell.
Reviewed by bought "Pecan Tarts aka Tassies, Caramel Cups, Pies" on our website
04/10/2019 - 08:45:23 PM
Texas Treat from Ohio
My family in Indiana are accustomed to getting pecan treats from us here in Texas; but, this is the first time they received one from Ohio!? We ALL love pecans and these little tarts did not let us down, WONDERFUL!
Reviewed by suepelton
04/10/2019 - 08:11:23 PM
Pecan Tassies
Will never make them myself again! Not when you have it down to a science!
Reviewed by Carol
04/05/2019 - 03:55:25 PM
great taste/great service
This bite sized treats are sooo good. I am from the south and we pride ourselves on our pecan pie. These are like little bitty pies. They are very tasty.
Reviewed by
03/27/2019 - 01:14:40 AM
i love everything so far
these are super good too...i am trying everything..
Reviewed by Becky Dixon
03/15/2019 - 05:49:37 PM
Cookies ordered
I wanted to take some Youngstown food to a dinner meeting. All attendees were exceptionally impressed with the baked goods. I was proud to bring some new food from my hometown to a South Carolina table.
Thank you Butter Maid Bakery!
Reviewed by Linda Kelley
03/04/2019 - 03:08:17 PM
pecan tarts
ohhhh yummy, taste just like pecan pie only better. my husband and I love them. you are great bakers, and thank you so much, also thanks for fast shipping.
Reviewed by Elizabeth Scheide
02/28/2019 - 01:33:45 PM
These tarts ave exceptionaslly tasty. Rich and full of pecans with a light delicious crust. So good, one is not
enough. Yum.
Reviewed by Alice S
02/17/2019 - 01:41:25 PM
The tassies are absolutely the best I’ve ever had.
Reviewed by Cindy
12/03/2017 - 11:15:30 AM
Pecan tarts
Awesome...the perfect dessert. Not too big, not too sweet!
Reviewed by Anita Kish
12/01/2017 - 07:51:14 PM
Just Like Mom Used to Make
Loved the nut tarts. The dough is exactly what I grew up with ever Chistmas. Perfect! Arrived in complete tarts, nothing damaged or smoothed.
Reviewed by Donna
11/29/2017 - 02:34:49 AM
Kolachis, Tassies and shipment time
I have absolutely loved the nut and poppyseed rolls! I have placed several orders this year. They are very similar to my Grandmother's, and I haven't found them anywhere as good as yours. Thank you for the memories we get from eating them! I tried the Apple Cinnamon Roll, but it tasted too similar to the nut roll for me. I ordered the Pecan Tassies for the first time, but I found it lacking in a creamy moist center as a pecan pie would be. A moist center has been my experience with Pecan Tassies, so I felt that they were soft and "all pecans." I do not like to complain, as I am thrilled to have found Butter Maid Bakery, but I probably won't order the Tassies again. Also, I have never paid for quick shipping, as I would think it would be imperative for an order to arrive as soon as possible for best taste and freshness, especially for something sent that wasn't a roll (rolls seems to do better). My order has always come in about three days. However, this time, my order was shipped early Wednesday morning and did not arrive until Monday mid afternoon. I live in Florida, so any food sitting for that long waiting to be delivered probably isn't the best representation of the product. Maybe because it included a weekend. All that being said, I am thrilled to be able to give my family members a taste of "Grandma's" nut and poppyseed rolls! Thank you for making that possible! God bless you, and Merry Christmas to all of your Butter Maid Bakery Family!
Reviewed by Kim
11/28/2017 - 09:49:40 AM
Pecan tarts
I bought these for my husband and he said they were great.
Reviewed by Caroline S
11/23/2017 - 11:08:21 PM
great pecan tarts
Pecan tarts are very tasty: loaded with nuts.
Well-packaged, fresh and sent quickly.
Reviewed by Carrie Taylor
11/18/2017 - 01:35:29 PM
Pecan Tarts
AMAZING!! The best I've ever had!
Reviewed by Takoya Stauts
11/15/2017 - 04:08:56 PM
5 Star
I️ did not get any but my boyfriend said they were amazing!
Reviewed by Bzy Lady
10/20/2017 - 01:49:58 PM
Pecan Tarts aka Tassies
They arrived in perfect condition. I have frozen them until Thanksgiving. So, so far so good
Reviewed by Mareesu
Mareesu bought "Pecan Tarts aka Tassies, Caramel Cups, Pies" on our website
10/11/2017 - 04:32:19 PM
Pecan Tassies!
Thank goodness I found this bakery! It's like mom is back with us! Thank you!
Reviewed by Larry Benson
10/08/2017 - 09:13:54 PM
Same as others, I used to receive these from a friend who stopped making them in her 90s, I loved them. Now I have a place to get them without bothering my too tired friend
Reviewed by kennethhartman
08/14/2017 - 03:12:38 PM
Pecan Tarts
DELICIOUS! Shouting from Middle Tennessee!
Reviewed by Ann Smith
07/21/2017 - 08:27:04 PM
Pecan Tarts
I have to admit that these tarts are by far the best I've had. I have also enjoyed other products you make and will have to visit in person one day since you are only about 45 minutes away. Flaky crust an fantasti filling, you can't go wrong!
Reviewed by Joyce Gennette
05/22/2017 - 02:40:09 PM
I ordered the Honey Walnut bread after seeing your add on facebook. I have ordered other things that way and just hoped I would not be disappointed. Well I wasn't it was the best nut bread I have ever eaten (and I have tried plenty!!) and I will never order it from anyone other then you again!! It came quickly and the price for the taste and the size was worth every penny. I hope you will be around a very long time cause I will be back. Thank you so much!
Reviewed by Patricia Davis
12/10/2016 - 04:59:48 PM
Nut Rolls
Received the nut rolls yesterday along with the pecan tarts. Opened up the pecan tarts and they were gone by the evening. Opened up one nut roll today and it's nearly gone. They were all so very good. I can hardly wait for the reduced sugar one. These were delicious but I had ordered one of the reduced sugar before and it was just perfect for me. I waited too long this time to place my order and wasn't able to order the cookies. My fault. I've been seeing my pain management doctor several times a month and I am saving one of the nut rolls for him and his assistant.
Reviewed by Joanne Cryer
07/20/2016 - 07:21:00 PM
Wonderful pastries - fast service. Yum !!!! I only wish they were in my town. I'd be there every week.
Reviewed by Helen
11/18/2011 - 09:33:16 AM
pecan tarts
order 2166
My Pa cousin always made these for the holidays. When she passed away at 96 we thought that tradition was gone.
You have now made a surprise for my visiting family at the holidays. I ordered to try these for Thanksgiving and they are wonderful!!! Just like "home"!!!
They are rich and full of pecans. And best they aren't too sugar sweet!!! Just right like a wonderful pecan pie. I have tried to make these and have failed to get the texture right...YOU SCORE!!!!!!! Many thanks...I'll be back!!!!
Our Customers Say...

We ordered a kolachi walnut roll for Christmas. OMG these seriously were one of the best I have ever had. The packaging was great...the delivery was quick..and the taste was sooo good. And the price was perfect.. So happy to have found you on the internet and will continue to order from you! Thanks for the great product!
Read More>>
Thank you so much for the incredible nut rolls my Mom received for her 79th birthday. I checked on-line your reviews for what you bake- great and true reviews... My Mom was amazed at how home made these tasted. She used to grind her own nuts and follow her Mom's recipe to make these for Christmas for neighbors and family. What a great feeling ...
Read More>>
Dear Butter Maid Bakery, Thank you for the Christmas cookies, they were awesome. You brought smiles to our faces over the holiday. We are a great nation & military, due to folks like you. Happy New Year and God Bless
Read More>>