Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll

Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll
Click to enlarge

More images


Product is out of stock


Not just for Thanksgiving, this fall favorite is a Christmas Holiday best seller. But hurry, like most flavors during holiday seasons, we won't be able bake them the entire holiday.

Pumpkin Walnut combines everything we love about pumpkin pie & The Original Nut Kolachi Roll.  Real pumpkin, fresh ground walnuts, sweet cream buttery dough & our secret pumpkin pie spice blend... filling our bakery with the irresistible smell of pumpkin pie, hot out of the oven! Serve warm and you'll never switch back... vanilla ice cream or whipped cream optional =)

Bakers Pro Tip: Stock your freezer. Regular customers are known to buy cases of 12 to freeze. This Fall best seller can be hard to keep available, and when they're gone they won't be back until next year.

Each roll comes whole, not sliced - about 14" long. Slice to preferred thickness, usually between 18-28 slices. May freeze up to 6 months.


Product Reviews

Reviewed by Terri DelMasso
12/30/2019 - 02:22:25 PM
Walnut pumpkin roll
Absolutely delicious items arrived quickly and with instuctions on storing and serving will order afmgain for all of our events
Reviewed by Betty L.
12/29/2019 - 01:27:36 PM
Dunkin Pumpkin
Absolutely 5 Stars for the pumpkin nut rolls.
They are most and spicy and delicious. Enjoyed
every bite.
Reviewed by gabby53
12/28/2019 - 07:13:56 PM
Pumpkin Walnut
Delicious! Can taste the different spices.
Reviewed by Nancy McPherson
12/28/2019 - 03:21:53 PM
Delicious Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll
This was my very first order from Butter Maid Bakery. It arrived earlier than expected and, with the vacuum packing, was as fresh as if it had just come out of the oven. I love pumpkin anything and, paired with walnuts, is a most delicious filling choice. I definitely will order again!
Reviewed by Leontine53@earthlink.net
Leontine53@earthlink.net bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
12/26/2019 - 08:45:38 AM
I sent this to my son for Christmas as he is a pumpkin lover and he raved about it. It's on my list to order for myself once it's back in stock!!
Reviewed by Charlie Buddock
12/24/2019 - 11:29:17 PM
Great Flavor!
Just tried a piece of the pumpkin walnut roll and couldn't believe the great flavor it had, as fresh as it just came out of the oven.
Reviewed by Bob
12/23/2019 - 08:49:00 PM
Thanks, but no thanks
Not even almost worth the 40 bucks that I spent on two rolls. Tossed them both in the garbage.
Reviewed by Dick
12/18/2019 - 09:19:18 PM
Nostalgic Nut Roll
I grew up around many Eastern European families that made what I remember as nut roll. All the kalachi rolls I’ve had are excellent and remind me of times long ago as I smelled the freshly made rolls and if I was lucky the kind neighbor lady would give me a small piece. These Buttermade rolls are the best I’ve had since. Their service is great. I feel like they are the neighbors
Reviewed by MimiD
12/18/2019 - 03:54:49 AM
Always Fresh and Truly A Homemade Flavor
My son's and I love these loaves, especially the Pumpkin Nut and Apple Cinnamon. Consistently fresh and flavorful. I freeze them and take slices out to defrost as we eat them. I love them warm with a little butter and a fresh cup of coffee! Thanks for such a quality baked good!
Reviewed by Betty Lezousky
12/16/2019 - 06:40:14 PM
I loved the Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi so much that I
sent it to about 6 friends for Christmas and birthdays.
The flavor just went zing when it hit my mouth, and I just reorder more for myself! It should be a permanent selection. Thanks for doing all that work.

Reviewed by Anita McCoy
12/09/2019 - 05:09:26 PM
Pumpkin/Walnut Roll
My family really enjoyed the Pumpkin/Walnut Roll. It was very moist and fresh. Arrived very quickly.
Reviewed by Tammie
12/08/2019 - 07:49:07 AM
Very fresh, can really taste the pumpkin. Bought 2 more that I froze for Christmas. Arrived in time for Thanksgiving. Excellent!
Reviewed by Jerilynne Messsenger
12/07/2019 - 07:38:54 PM
Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi
This kolachi is just like having pumpking pie, without the work. Spices are just right -- not too strong yet enough to make it delicious! I freeze some of your kolachis and they always taste fresh when I remove them from the freezer for special meals and events.
Reviewed by Sandy Holmes
12/05/2019 - 05:25:53 PM
GREAT!! Wish I had ordered two!!
The pumpkin was very noticeable in the loaf. I've loved every bite!
Reviewed by Kiernan
12/05/2019 - 02:49:48 PM
Order a few rolls to test them out. Boy am I glad I did. Had the pumpkin and apple for Thanksgiving and they were the hit of the dessert table! I also got a chocolate one, which is patiently awaiting us in the freezer. After trying the first two, I can only imagine how good the chocolate one will be. Bookmarked this site for future orders. Will definitely be ordering again!
Reviewed by Kristy J
12/05/2019 - 02:49:43 PM
Bought this for my son & daughter-in-law for Thanksgiving morning. She is a pumpkin lover and said this was the most delicious thing she has ever eaten. Highly Recommended!!
Reviewed by Meagan
12/05/2019 - 09:09:58 AM
Pumpkin Roll
We ordered two rolls for thanksgiving this year, our mother in law makes kolachi, so we tried two flavors that she normally wouldn't make. The pumpkin Kolachi was amazing, and I really enjoyed the Honey Walnut as well! Buttermaid Bakery knocked it out of the park. We will definitely be ordering again! Thanks from Columbus, Ohio!
Reviewed by Janice M. Brubaker
12/05/2019 - 02:23:32 AM
My husband loves this one. I believe it's going to be ordered again next year!
Reviewed by Jeff S
12/04/2019 - 08:34:14 PM
Awesome Product
I have never ordered the pumpkin walnut kolachi before but it was excellent. I would recommend it to anyone.
Reviewed by Reese
12/04/2019 - 01:03:44 PM
Ordered the pumpkin and apple rolls.. Very good :) Will definitely order again :)
Reviewed by Linda Shroyer
12/04/2019 - 09:45:29 AM
I received this for Thanksgiving! Everyone loved it and no leftovers! It was fresh and yummy!
Reviewed by Cheryl
12/03/2019 - 10:23:59 PM
Pumpkin Walnut Roll
Delivered in perfect shape in a very timely manner. DELICIOUS!
Reviewed by Beth
12/03/2019 - 09:47:43 PM
The pumpkin nut roll was awesome .would recommend heating them a little so good .Thank You .Enjoy all.
Reviewed by cminks1109
cminks1109 bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
12/03/2019 - 05:14:03 PM
Pumpkin nut Roll
I order one and it came really fast and was really yummy.
Thanks ot tasted really fresh.
Reviewed by Andrew
12/03/2019 - 02:03:09 PM
Pumpkin Walnut roll
I love pumpkin so it was great! If you don't love pumpkin get the regular walnut roll.
Reviewed by Trish
12/03/2019 - 06:28:15 AM
So Good!
I but 3 of the pumpkin walnut rolls for Thanksgiving. 1st time I ordered and will definitely be ordering again! the
Delicious, packaged well and enjoyed by everyone! Brought back memories of my mother!
Reviewed by Ann Wilkie
12/02/2019 - 11:28:25 PM
Pumpkin Walnut
This flavor has become my favorite!
Reviewed by Lorenzo
12/02/2019 - 01:34:10 PM
OMG. It was amazing. So. Worth the price and especially the taste.
Reviewed by Monica Roush
12/02/2019 - 10:14:03 AM
The pumpkin walnut roll is so delicious! I’m glad I ordered 2! I’m happy they freeze/thaw well! Yum!!
Reviewed by john jurovich
12/01/2019 - 01:49:44 PM
Pumpkin Walnut
Delicious flavor melt in your mouth good.
Reviewed by Barbara
11/30/2019 - 10:08:47 PM
Thanks for your pumpkin roll. It was a wonderful Thanksgiving treat.
However, for the year around goodie, your low sugar is so appreciated, especially for those of us that love your products but need to watch our sugar intake.

Reviewed by Cathy Ollie
11/30/2019 - 12:52:51 PM
Pumpkin walnut k
Your product is wonderful always delicious and fresh tasty like home made just like my baba used to make back in my youth so many wonderful memories thank y’all for your hard work and dedication
Reviewed by Christine
11/30/2019 - 11:18:03 AM
Thanksgiving treat
First time trying pumpkin and it was a hit! I will order again.
Reviewed by Tony Kruzik
11/28/2019 - 12:56:37 PM
Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll
No skimping on the filling and Very Delicious.
Reviewed by zukauska@optonline.net
zukauska@optonline.net bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
11/27/2019 - 04:00:25 PM
I sent a Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi bread to my 94 year old Aunt who has made traditional Slovak poppyseed and walnut breads her whole life.
It arrived exactly when expected and made her day! All she could say in her thank-you note was that she "had a delicious breakfast...Mmmm!"
Thank you for making her day.
Reviewed by Rhoada Hruska
11/27/2019 - 02:33:27 PM
pumpkin walnut roll
I had a large order including 6 of these.We opened one right away because we knew how delicious it would be.Saved 2 for Thanksgiving and gave the rest to family. My next order will be going out soon.
Reviewed by Mskat1954
Mskat1954 bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
11/26/2019 - 09:51:57 PM
Pumpkin time
Soooooo Good!!!
Almost like pumpkin pie
My daughter loved it & she hates walnuts.
Shipped to Florida. Excellent packed
Reviewed by Richard Schreiber
11/25/2019 - 11:49:02 AM
Absolutely fantastic 5 stars
I bought original, pumpkin walnut and honey walnut. My favorite like grandma used to make was the pumpkin walnut. What a nice addition to the walnut with extra flavor like pumpkin pie. So I bought 3 for my daughter so she can know what her great grandma made for us in younger days.
Reviewed by Brad
11/24/2019 - 07:43:07 PM
Delicious and now want to try every other flavor, ordering more for thanksgiving
Reviewed by aronders1
aronders1 bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
11/22/2019 - 08:03:43 PM
Pumpkin Walnut Roll
I bought a pumpkin walnut roll. I ate some and froze some. It was delicious. The roll arrived in a timely fashion via USPS. This was my second order and I will order again. Five stars for Butter Maid
Reviewed by Patty
11/22/2019 - 04:49:12 PM
Pumpkin Roll
I love pumpkin everything and it should be year round. Nummy stuff...thanks
Reviewed by Shaun
Shaun bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
11/22/2019 - 03:05:16 PM
Excellent food and service
Reviewed by Linda Rae
11/22/2019 - 12:35:11 PM
Tastes like home
Every single bite was delicious ! It tasted like home
Reviewed by Susan
11/22/2019 - 08:39:04 AM
The best!
These kolachis are simply the best! My mom grew up in Youngstown and her relatives would send these for the holidays. I'm so happy I can now order online and have these delicious memories of my childhood!
Reviewed by Carl
11/21/2019 - 09:15:42 AM
Always fresh, great addition to the Thanksgiving desserts
Reviewed by cslick
cslick bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
11/15/2019 - 05:54:15 PM
We ordered the new flavor of pumpkin nut. As always, the roll was fantastic!!
Reviewed by Thomas Iatarola
11/15/2019 - 06:56:29 AM
Great for the holidays
The pumpkin walnut combo roll was just excellent and perfect for the holidays. It was a big hit for morning coffee, and fir a snak at night. Thank you for a great holiday mixture.
Reviewed by Rick - Altoona, PA
11/14/2019 - 09:21:39 AM
Nice change
The pumpkin walnut Kolachi was a nice change for the holidays! It has a unique pumpkin flavor that is absolutely delicious! I have one in the freezer to serve for Thanksgiving desert. I plan on ordering more! A definite WINNER!
Reviewed by Harriet
11/13/2019 - 04:46:46 PM
Pumpkin walnut roll
These are absolutely my favorite! I wish they could be ordered year round.
Reviewed by Shirley Dorsett
11/10/2019 - 12:39:26 PM
where have you been?
I found your advertisement in my local paper and just had to try it. Oh my!!!!!!!!! I would almost choose this over regular pumpkin pie. The taste is divine. The dough is so, so it leaves me speechless. Will buy from again.
Reviewed by Alberta
11/08/2019 - 04:11:17 PM
I connected with my Polish cousin after 40 years. He introduced me to your wonderful bakery and I have been buying from you since. These are perfectly made just as I was a kid. Thank you, great Christmas presents.
Reviewed by Kathy
11/05/2019 - 09:17:53 AM
This was my first time ordering from Butter Maid Bakery. Growing up eating Kolachi from the ethnic churches in my town, this was by far the best. Comes in a seal a meal bag which it keeps it very moist. I froze the walnut one for Christmas, but this pumpkin one was Superb. We loved it. Will definitely order again.
Reviewed by Brenda
11/04/2019 - 01:16:31 PM
Pumpkin Delish
I purchased this early, in preparation for Thanksgiving. I was very impressed with how beautifully it was packaged & loved the personalized touch of a hand written note from the bakery "quality control" auditor! I plan to serve mine on Thanksgiving morning for breakfast with pumpkin spice coffee/lattes pre workout!
Reviewed by Mary Ann
11/04/2019 - 03:08:40 AM
Everyone I gave them to really enjoyed them. Will buy again for holidays. They aren't exactly pretty but oh so tasty. Wish the variety pack came with 4 half sized boxes. Hard to wrap as 4 gifts.
Reviewed by Laverne
11/01/2019 - 07:08:33 PM
It's our favorite dessert. No matter the flavor they are all delicious!
Reviewed by leichtl
leichtl bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
11/01/2019 - 11:08:22 AM
Nice Fall Treat
I added the Pumpkin Walnut roll to my usual Poppy Seed roll (my 94-year old dad´s favorite) order. What a great surprise. I really liked it.
Reviewed by Fran Mac
10/31/2019 - 02:14:54 PM
Pumpkin Walnut
Would like to try this with less sugar.
Reviewed by Shirley39
Shirley39 bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
10/30/2019 - 02:58:16 PM
Best thing since sliced bread
I bought this Malachi after seeing an advertisement in my local paper. Oh my!!!!!! Best money I've spent on sweets. Highly recommend these. It's like eating a piece of heaven. It taste better than my pumpkin pie!!!!
Reviewed by Michele
10/25/2019 - 06:28:06 PM
Very good
First time trying and was not disappointed. Not to sweet which I really liked and perfect amount of filling.
Reviewed by Peggy Rygiel
10/22/2019 - 02:29:23 PM
The Best
The pumpkin Walnut nut roll was wonderful. We have ordered other flavors in the past, and have always been very pleased. Looking forward to ordering more.
Reviewed by sue.laronde@aecom.com
sue.laronde@aecom.com bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
10/22/2019 - 08:05:11 AM
Yummy for Fall
I've purchased the Nut Roll 3 years in a row. This year I also added the Pumpkin Roll for Fall. My husband and I have eaten the whole thing. It's so Yummy!
Reviewed by Don
10/21/2019 - 04:54:33 PM
Pumpkin Roll
Delicious, never had a pumpkin roll made like that.
They usually have cream cheese in them. Yours are
Reviewed by Lynne C
10/21/2019 - 04:26:38 PM
Pumpkin nut roll
Heavily-stuffed roll, great combination of pumpkin nut flavor. So yummy good, froze some for later.
Reviewed by Mary Muchowicz
10/13/2019 - 10:07:05 AM
My favorite
The pumpkin walnut kolachi roll was the best. We'd cut a slice and heat it 20 seconds in the microwave. This was such a treat.
Reviewed by ernieazar
ernieazar bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
10/11/2019 - 03:46:45 PM
Pumpkin kolachi
First time I tried it and was very good
Reviewed by John Skrabalak
10/11/2019 - 12:16:19 AM
Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll
I was disappointed in this roll...could hardly taste any pumpkin...tried warming it up...that didn't help...It was good as a basic nut roll, but no pumpkin flavor.
Reviewed by Mary Poninski, Arizona
10/10/2019 - 11:30:15 PM
Daughter's Birthday in Illinois
Sent the pumpkin walnut to my dayghter for her birthday. She said it was the best of all her gifts and hooe I will send her one evry birthday from now on!
She said it was gone in an hour after receiving itand that it was delicious! Thank you for having such and easy website for ordering and fantastic products!
Reviewed by Laura Lee Hall
10/10/2019 - 09:53:39 AM
Pumpkin and cheese kolachi
these flavors are, as usual with you guys, wonderful. Any place mass producing won't have them. They are a little bit of heaven on this earth! Now that Mom's generation is gone, I'm glad I found someone to bake so I don't have to do all the work! Ten Stars**********!
Reviewed by Charlie D
10/10/2019 - 09:05:12 AM
Great gift
I purchased this as a gift for a friend who loves the fall season but know nothing about kolachi! Excellent addition ! This one didn't last long! Looking forward to my next pick...
Reviewed by Terry
10/07/2019 - 05:12:30 PM
Pumpkin walnut roll
Nice fall dessert. I never had this before but it is a nice Thanksgiving dessert.
Reviewed by Cathy
10/07/2019 - 09:38:33 AM
Pumpkin Nut Roll
Delicious! Filled with a warm pumpkin taste perfect for Fall. Definitely will order again.
Reviewed by Mary L Ryan
10/05/2019 - 09:06:15 AM
Pumpkin Walnut&Prune-Delicious!!
I am all-over Pumpkin in the Fall/Winter and was very pleased with this roll!! I've had the Prune before and loved it, too. Haven't had a bad Kolachi so far!!
Reviewed by Paul
10/03/2019 - 04:50:45 PM
Slightly disappointed
The roll followed today's trends - more pumpkin spice than pumpkin. I know taste is subjective, but for me, I like to taste the pumpkin vs. the spices. However, the product is good - just disappointed it wasn't better.
Reviewed by Patti
10/03/2019 - 01:14:46 PM
It is the best of all flavors by far.
Reviewed by AL O
10/02/2019 - 04:33:34 PM
Loved it
Reviewed by billbear
billbear bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
10/02/2019 - 03:13:35 PM
simply a great fall taste
i just got my pumpkin kolachi roll and it tastes amazing putting me early into the fall season for tastes and small.each kolachi gets seems to get better and better ive have ordered 5 now and have been overwhelmed with how great each one has tasted thank you for being you
Reviewed by Bonnie
09/28/2019 - 10:05:28 AM
Reminds me of Grandma’s kitchen
This was so delicious, way beyond my expectations. Brings me back to the days of being in the kitchen with my Grandmother, and learning how to make her delicious kolachi, which were honey walnut and poppyseed. Hers were always finished with a sweet glaze, which I do with the ButterMaid kolachis before I serve them to guests on the holidays. So very happy I found you
Reviewed by Edward Vavra
09/28/2019 - 07:54:38 AM
Pumpkin Walnut Roll
This roll was even better than expected. The pumpkin/walnut combination is very delicious and goes well together. I would highly recommend it to everyone. I will give this a five star rating.
Reviewed by Eileen
09/26/2019 - 07:14:41 AM
Pumpkin walnut roll
Like eating a little taste of heaven
Reviewed by Mary Minjeur
09/25/2019 - 06:32:42 PM
i like the Kolachi for the most part, but I find the dough is kind of thin and pasty which doesn't give the "swirls" to see after they are sliced. I ordered the raspberry walnut as well and the seeds are bothersome in my teeth after I eat them. I love raspberries though! Hmm. I haven't eaten the pumpkin-walnut as I am saving them for my son and his wife who are having a dinner and I was bring these for their dessert.
I don't like to criticize but I guess I'm used to my grandmother and mother making Kolacha which was a little different. Anyway, your's is still the best tasting that I know of anywhere! Thanks for listening.
Reviewed by postalcarolyn
postalcarolyn bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
09/24/2019 - 12:01:24 PM
Pumpkin roll
Ordered as a gift for someone who loves everything pumpkin. She loved it.
Reviewed by Dusti
09/23/2019 - 08:51:19 PM
A Winner
This was my first time ordering the Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi and definitely won’t be the last. It was very delicious and a tasty treat.
Reviewed by LeaAnne
09/22/2019 - 03:10:21 PM
Pumpkin Kolachi
Having grown up on kolachi for all special events I look forward to serving this unique fall flavor for our son's October wedding rehearsal dinner. However the price for the size of the kolach is expensive. My church sells them for $11 and they are the same size.
Reviewed by Rita
09/21/2019 - 02:47:14 PM
Pumpkin Walnut
Have a wedding approaching so ordered several of these for the breakfast, the morning after. We have tried one and though it was good we are not thrilled with it. Wish we could have gotten the pumpkin with cream cheese but it is not offered at this time. Will let you know how everyone responds to these.
Reviewed by Cathy Yurkewycz
09/21/2019 - 01:02:37 AM
The best!
Absolutely delicious! Light on dough and heavy on the filling. All very fresh and delightful!
Reviewed by Steven
09/20/2019 - 04:58:12 PM
First time Pumpkin Kolachi Buyer
First, I love Buttermaid Walnut Kolachi rolls. Second, I love all things Pumpkin; pie, biscotti, beer - you get the idea. So I thought that this would be another item on my favorite Pumpkin list. While I thought it was decent, some of the spices were a bit overpowering and it wasn't my favorite. I probably won't get this again. Personally, I will continue to stick with the basic Walnut Kolachi rolls that I - and the friends I give them to - devour. That being said, that's my taste. Don't let this review deter you from trying it. Your tastes might be different and you might really like this.
Reviewed by Sandy Thorwarth
09/20/2019 - 03:33:11 PM
My cousin loved loved loved it!!!
Reviewed by Glenn
09/19/2019 - 10:35:35 PM
Fast shipping, great item.
Reviewed by MaryBethB
MaryBethB bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
09/19/2019 - 01:29:04 PM
Pumpkin walnut roll
I ordered this out of curiosity as we like pumpkin and, of course, walnut roll, which happen to be our family's personal favorite. We LOVED this! The pumpkin flavor is there without being overpowering. I ordered two of the pumpkin walnut and my grown kids fought over it!! This is definitely a fun seasonal roll to try!
Reviewed by Barbara
09/19/2019 - 01:10:18 PM
Worth the wait
First time pumpkin but won't be the last. Too bad this is only available seasonally.
Reviewed by Aunt Pattyca
09/18/2019 - 01:31:14 PM
Pumpkin Potica
You call it what you will, but to me, it's Potica...and it was SO yummy. And so glad for the pumpkin flavored season.
Reviewed by Arnold
Arnold bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
09/17/2019 - 08:21:24 AM
Nut rolls
Have tried several of the different nut rolls and they all were most excellent, just like my mother and grandmothers used to make. They are long gone but your nut rolls bring back many memories. The pumpkin walnut is new to me but it too is fantastic. Thank you Butter Maid.
Reviewed by Kosma2
Kosma2 bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
09/17/2019 - 01:54:46 AM
Pumpkin Walnut Roll
What a perfect combination for this time of year!! It was as fresh and and generously filled like every roll that I have purchased! And as always shipped immediately! These folks are definitely doing it right!!!
Reviewed by Barbara J Wipke
09/16/2019 - 09:06:41 PM
Pumpkin walnut
This was an amazing mix of pumpkin and walnut. It was delicious. I would definitely buy again.
Reviewed by Kcba42
Kcba42 bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
09/16/2019 - 08:45:55 PM
Card playing favorite
Sent to my Dad.... he is retired and plays a lot of cards with his buddies. Great snack to share with them!
Reviewed by Margaret Viands
09/16/2019 - 06:08:43 PM
Hit as a gift
Gifted the pumpkin walnut kolachi to my Mother. She’s a fan, said I could buy more anytime. Makes a great anytime snack. Thank you Buttermaid for the consistency of putting out great products. We’ve never had anything from you that was not wonderful.
Reviewed by Joe Yannick
09/16/2019 - 03:21:29 PM
Pumpkin walnut
We have tried several of the flavors that Butter Maid bakery sells and have been more than happy with each and every one but the pumpkin walnut kolachi is a homerun. Just perfect for a slice of heaven at breakfast or dessert (or really just anytime) it is great!
Reviewed by Brian Stofko
09/16/2019 - 01:49:54 PM
Disappointed with Pumpkin
Bought the pumpkin kolachi due to hype as well as other kolachis (not my first kolachi order).
Received the order in a few days and tried the pumpkin first. I was sorely disappointed in the flavor of this kolachi and will not be ordering it again. Just very bland and tasteless to me, unlike the others I’ve had before.
Reviewed by Cissy
Cissy bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
09/16/2019 - 01:39:39 PM
What a perfect Fall flavor - another "home run."
Reviewed by Sck72aek
Sck72aek bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
09/16/2019 - 12:22:37 AM
The pumpkin walnut kolachi was moist and delicious and like my Grandma Susan use to make.
Reviewed by Gina
09/15/2019 - 02:19:51 PM
Love it
I really like the pumpkin but did think the pumpkin flavor could have been a little stronger but still loved it.
Reviewed by Sara B
09/13/2019 - 01:20:15 PM
Good but...
The cinnamon flavor was great but the pumpkin flavor I was hoping to taste was lacking any strength to match the spices blend. I wanted to taste a sweet pumpkin flavor but I was disappointed. It was barely there at all.
Reviewed by Jenn
12/02/2018 - 12:40:37 PM
I was surprised by my mother sending me Kolachi while in college here in Chicago. Growing up in Michigan we always had Kolachi for Christmas. It is my favorite dessert! Thank you for the delicious pumpkin walnut Kolachi and the raspberry Kolachi. Thank you
Reviewed by Santa Fe Kaye
12/04/2017 - 05:54:56 PM
Just right!
This was the first time I had tried the pumpkin roll. It was delicious! The pumpkin flavor was very mellow, making it not taste like pumpkin pie (which I love). When our family gets together for holiday breakfast, we always have some sort of sweet bread and this roll was the PERFECT accompaniment. Thank you Butter Maid for making such a wonderful addition to your variety of rolls!
Reviewed by Jeri
12/04/2017 - 09:29:20 AM
Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi
Ordered as a gift, this kolachi was a big hit. This was the 3rd flavor of kolachi purchased for my brother and each has been excellent. Shipping was immediate and well packaged.
Reviewed by Gini
12/04/2017 - 01:14:03 AM
First X Buyer
Delightful, not to sweet, perfect.
Reviewed by Denise
12/02/2017 - 06:57:16 PM
Very tasty
This was very tasty. I never had it with pumpkin before
Reviewed by Carl Sparks
12/02/2017 - 01:57:18 PM
First timer perfection
I don’t know what I was expecting but this loaf was amazing. Served it with my Thanksgiving meal. I will be ordering again. Thank you!
Reviewed by Maria A
12/01/2017 - 10:57:11 PM
Happiness Is
The Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Rolls brought happiness to the room. The rolls offered a delicious alternative to typical Thanksgiving pies. Served warm with or without vanilla ice cream and/or whipped cream, and everyone was happy.
Reviewed by Sherri
12/01/2017 - 08:21:38 PM
Easy to serve, fresh, and a hit! Everyone loved it!
Reviewed by Leo Bonaventura
12/01/2017 - 03:46:28 PM
Hit of the brunch
After a 10k run we have a brunch on Thanksgiving and this was gone before I could have a piece
Reviewed by Patti
12/01/2017 - 01:08:22 PM
Pumpkin Kolache
This was so very good. Served at a driveway party and everyone raved. Had to come clean that I did not make it. You may be getting lots of orders coming your way.
Reviewed by Pumpkin Nut and Walnut Raisin
11/30/2017 - 07:40:47 PM
Excellent packaging, tremendous taste. A great first time experience.
Reviewed by gwen chupka
11/30/2017 - 07:25:36 PM
My husband said this kolach reminded him of his mother's home made kolach from the church from long ago. Was moist and had so much filling. I will order again and spread the work to others. GREAT JOB!!
Reviewed by Pat Hahl
11/30/2017 - 01:15:42 PM
Pumpkin nut
This is the first time I have ordered but will not be the last! Delicious!
Reviewed by Scott
11/30/2017 - 03:09:33 AM
Never had this before
This put a smile on my face. Very interesting flavor just explodes in your mouth. I didn't share the pumpkin one with anyone because I loved it so much. I just ordered one and wanted it to last till Christmas.

Reviewed by Tracy
11/29/2017 - 09:28:21 PM
Will order again delicious and fresh
Very good! A real hit at the family Thanksgiving meal! Will order again soon for Christmas.
Reviewed by Lynn
11/29/2017 - 06:44:06 PM
It was wonderful fresh moist and tasted awesome
Reviewed by Kathy Frostu
11/29/2017 - 06:28:13 PM
Pumpkin Roll
This was definitely well received from workers to family. It was a resounding success!! In fact, I was asked for the recipe. To me, that speaks volumes to both myself and ButterMaid.
Reviewed by Chris
11/29/2017 - 04:26:18 PM
The Pumpkin Walnut was Fabulous. Soft and sweet but not overly sweet.
Reviewed by Sally
11/29/2017 - 01:05:57 PM
Thanksgiving day delight
Very enjoyable and nice treat for Thanksgiving
Reviewed by Pat Kasap
11/29/2017 - 06:46:20 AM
Breakfast treat
I love pumpkin everything ... pie, muffins, bread, and now Kolachi. I could have devoured it completely when it first arrived. Fortunately, self-control won, so I froze half and refrigerated the rest. Each morning I allow myself a slice of heaven with my coffee ... the perfect start to a fall day. I alternate with the apple cinnamon and rasberry flavors. Each day I think, oh this is my favorite. Taste and texture ... they are all sublime.
Reviewed by Brewerbarr
Brewerbarr bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
11/29/2017 - 12:36:14 AM
Money well spent
Tried the pumpkin Kolachi roll for the first time. From the first bite on it was heaven! Saved part for Christmas to share with family. Will definitely order again. Well worth the price and just an excellent dessert. You can tell the ingredients are fresh and the real deal. Nothing artificial in this deliciousness!!
Reviewed by Sandy Coho
11/28/2017 - 08:21:43 PM
O!M!G! Yum!!!!
Big hit at thanksgiving! Wish i had purchased a few more!!! Delish!!!
Reviewed by Vicki Brown
11/28/2017 - 06:43:13 PM
The Pumpkin walnut is wonderful. I found it to be perfect in taste and quality. I will definetly reorder for Christmas. I froze it for a couple of weeks to save for Thanksgiving and stayed nice and fresh.
Reviewed by Nancy Boynton
11/28/2017 - 05:35:22 PM
I bought more than one kolachi as we had grown up on only one type, poppy seed. Well, to tell you the truth, we liked this better than our beloved poppy seed.
Reviewed by Kathleen Sabo
11/28/2017 - 08:51:59 AM
Pumpkin roll
It looked beautiful and my husband really liked but me not so much. I didn’t like the crust at all. It is way too soft and not like a pie crust .
Reviewed by Sarmento Silva
11/28/2017 - 08:31:24 AM
Happy Turkey Day
This just shouts HAPPY Thanksgiving. Great with some whipped cream and just right for that "OK I am stuffed like the Turkey but I can do a piece of that new Thanksgiving tradition"!
Reviewed by LindaSonia
11/27/2017 - 09:07:54 PM
Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi
My first order from you was the Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi and I was NOT disappointed. It was yummy. You wouldn't upset me if you bumped up the pumpkin flavor. I may just have to try every flavor.
Reviewed by Karen Gallagher
11/27/2017 - 07:45:35 PM
All my friends who tasted this said they would definitely buy it!
Reviewed by William T Epperson
11/26/2017 - 02:46:54 PM
Pumpkin Nut
Reviewed by Janet
11/25/2017 - 09:38:55 PM
Pumpkin Walnut R
It's in the freezer - put away for a special occasion but looks wonderful!!
Reviewed by Linda B
11/24/2017 - 03:08:26 PM
Pumpkin nut
Yum! Great alternative to pumpkin pie! Try it, you won’t regret!
Reviewed by Janie
11/24/2017 - 10:48:57 AM
I am a repeat customer and these kolachi's are the best ever. oh my gosh ! These ones barely made it to Thanksgiving once the grandkids found them in the freezer..lol. Will definately be ordering for Christmas. Brings back so many childhood memories from home.
Reviewed by Louise Buttermore
11/23/2017 - 01:14:29 AM
Pumpkin Kolachi
I won't order this again; just wasn't my cup of tea. However, I simply LOVE the original walnut roll -- it's just like my Baba's -- and I'll be ordering that again!!
Reviewed by Paula Clark
11/22/2017 - 10:30:19 AM
You won't be disappointed!
Absolutely AMAZING!!! The pumpkin is just the right amount. Every bite has filling. Will definitely order, again.
Reviewed by tomcreamer
tomcreamer bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
11/21/2017 - 05:14:32 PM
Love Pumpkin!!
My childhood favorite updated with pumpkin ... who woulda thought ... right? Love it!!
Reviewed by LARS
11/17/2017 - 08:56:57 PM
These rolls are delicious and so familiar if you grew up with "Kolachi" or "nut rolls." Which I did in an Italian family. You can taste all the ingredients fresh and just great quality. I gave one to a friend and their comment was: Oh my GOSH! I could just taste the butter and nuts in that and the pumpkin flavor was like homemade. I thought that was a great compliment!
Reviewed by Patti
11/17/2017 - 08:12:47 AM
Pumpkin Walnut.
I have not tried it yet but I am looking forward to having it for Thanksgiving so all my family can try it also.
Reviewed by Cathy Mullenix
11/16/2017 - 04:41:51 PM
Pumpkin Walnut!!
Reviewed by Donald G
11/16/2017 - 05:26:00 AM
I grew up eating walnut kolachi since I was 4 years old. I have am part Ukrainian and Italian. I've had kolachi from so many people and places, but NONE were ever this good. I was happily amazed at how moist it is and how much walnut filling is in it. All others I have tried were dry, NOT THIS ONE. The flavor is so fresh, buttery and moist. It is now a year round staple in our home.
Reviewed by tnjenkins
tnjenkins bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
11/15/2017 - 11:43:09 AM
Pumpkin Kolach
We absolutely loved this one!
Reviewed by Marilyn
11/05/2017 - 11:09:48 AM
Pumpkin Roll
I am your customer with no self-control. I was afraid to open the package for fear it would be gone too soon. It went right into the freezer for the holidays! I'm rating it high, as I know it will be excellent!
Reviewed by cjwrn
cjwrn bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
11/01/2017 - 07:32:08 PM
Just ok
Light pumpkin taste, hard to tell it was pumpkin. This is the first time I ordered. The rolls seemed very flat, guess I expected more of a traditional loaf shape.
Reviewed by DarleneC
11/01/2017 - 04:08:07 PM
Kolachi to die for!
Well, it's been years since my sister and I (who grew up in Sharon, PA and are now living in CA) had any Kolachi. What is a holiday without Kolachi, or life for that matter! I must say this was THE ABSOLUTE BEST KILLER KOLACHI EVER; so moist and flavorful. I've never had a Kolachi so moist and totally filled. There were no air pockets, and no dryness at all. I don't know how you did it, but it is truly amazing. The dough was almost like sweet bread, it was so moist and yummy. We will definitely be purchasing more since we devoured the first two. Thank you for the wonderful packaging too. You took such care in every step! Shrink wrapped the Kolachi and placed in their own boxes inside another box. They arrived without any dings or brusing. You took such care in every step of the process. This is why you have such a great product! Loving care with every step. Your grandparents would be so proud.
Reviewed by Cathy Tannenholz
11/01/2017 - 03:11:24 PM
Best Nut Roll
When my sister gave me your original nut roll to try I was skeptical at first. I get some very good homemade nut rolls where I live. But after my very first bite, Buttermaid’s nut roll is the best I’ve ever eaten! I recently tried the pumpkin nut and WOW! Can’t decide which one I like better. I don’t know how you do it but so very glad you do.
Reviewed by msmittzie
msmittzie bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
10/30/2017 - 08:43:07 AM
Great for the holidays!!
I have tried several different flavors of the Kolachi rolls and all have been good! Pumpkin Walnut was a little drier than the others but still good. I have to admit that the Poppyseed is still my very favorite!! Always so moist and lots of filling!! Just like my grandmother's!!!
Reviewed by ElaineB
10/23/2017 - 06:25:14 PM
Pumpkin Roll
I look forward to this product each fall. I am eating it right now. Products always arrive in great condition. I cut the abundant roll in half, eating one half and freezing the other. It tastes good months later!
Reviewed by Bzy Lady
10/20/2017 - 01:50:45 PM
Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll
They arrived in perfect condition. I have frozen them until Thanksgiving. So, so far so god
Reviewed by Linda
10/19/2017 - 07:04:04 PM
Where's the pumpkin?
Tastes wonderful but assumed there would be more pumpkin flavor. Mine was not
Reviewed by Jill123
10/12/2017 - 05:14:35 PM
Pumpkin Walnut
I bought three pumpkin kolachi rolls. I gave one to my mother, one to my favorite Aunt and Uncle, and the last one to my mother-in-law. Well they loved them so much that when I got home my mother-in-law ate the whole thing. I didn't even taste it :( . I'm ordering more for me haha!!! They are absolutely the best ever! You can call me one of your favorite customers!
Reviewed by Deborah
10/11/2017 - 06:03:40 PM
In holding pattern......
The pumpkin kolacki we ordered is presently in the freezer, to be opened in December. I will be more than happy to share my opinion of this when we serve the kolacki then.
Reviewed by Debra B
10/11/2017 - 04:42:25 PM
Fall Fabulous
Absolutely love the pumpkin walnut kolachi. Just the right amount of spice to pumpkin! Well done, folks!
Reviewed by Mareesu
Mareesu bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
10/11/2017 - 04:27:51 PM
Pumpkin/walnut kolachi
Amazing! Tried it on a whim! Ordered more!!
Reviewed by BarbaraPeggs
10/11/2017 - 03:31:20 PM
Pumpkin roll
The pumpkin kolach roll is wonderful. Just like my Grandma, Aunt and Mom used to make. I had to try it and ate all and had to buy more/
Reviewed by jlang0943
jlang0943 bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
10/10/2017 - 11:13:08 AM
Thanksgiving Treat
I ordered this last year and served it as a dessert on Thanksgiving. Everyone loved it. Wish it was available all year.
Reviewed by Christine Keiflin
10/09/2017 - 11:37:23 PM
Pumpkin/Nutroll Review
Delicious*just like Mom used to make. Lpve all your products.. done with perfection.
Reviewed by Christina Bankovic
10/03/2017 - 11:53:04 AM
Holy pumpkin roll!!!
Took one pumpkin kolach roll for after church fellowship coffee hour in Brunswick, Georgia. The cut kolach lasted less than five minutes. People came back for seconds, but too bad, so sad, all gone! The best I could do was to tell them to google Butter Maid and place their own order!!!
Reviewed by Joy Mislevy
10/03/2017 - 11:35:56 AM
I could eat this all year long. So yummy!
Reviewed by Harry Schultz
09/27/2017 - 01:58:38 PM
Not just for fall!
The pumpkin walnut was terrific. You need to make this year round!
Reviewed by Cheryl
09/26/2017 - 12:40:11 AM
Great flavor!
I really loved the pumpkin walnut nut roll! It was soooo good I had to ration how much I ate each day so I wouldn't run out too soon. I will be buying this again!
Reviewed by Sue west
09/25/2017 - 07:12:25 PM
Pumpkin nut roll
I love this seasonal roll! It's not a filling my grandmother used, but I adore this pumpkin roll! Thank you for great custumer service!
Reviewed by HLouise
09/22/2017 - 11:48:06 AM
The pumpkin walnut bread is delicious as are all the breads. I have 2 of each in my freezer as well as the cookies. I'd say I'm ready for the holidays, thanks to Butter Maid!
Reviewed by Andrea Schultz
09/21/2017 - 11:07:23 PM
Pumpkin Walnut, the absolute perfect fall flavor treat - enjoyed it so much that I even gave one to my sister for her birthday! Now, I'm waiting for another multi-order to come in - can't wait! It's that good!!! TY, ButterMaid! :)
Reviewed by Danielle
09/21/2017 - 10:01:06 PM
I recently ordered a pumpkin walnut Kolachi. I had never eaten one before but I thought it looked good and that I would give it a try. I ordered one for myself, my mom and a friend. Every agreed that it was fantastic. My mom said it was like eating a pumpkin pie. I ate almost the entire Kolachi by myself. I will definitely be ordering again.
Reviewed by Margaret
09/20/2017 - 10:11:48 PM
Pumpkin Nut Roll
The Pumpkin Nut Roll was wonderful. Would order it again.
Reviewed by Lizlindsley
Lizlindsley bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
09/20/2017 - 08:20:47 PM
Beyond Yummyrific
Truly incredible. Thank you.
Reviewed by WWK888
WWK888 bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
09/20/2017 - 04:04:03 PM
Pumpkin Walnut
It was very good, I would prefer a little more pumpkin flavor but I loved it. I shared it with a friend and they too loved it. Not too sweet, great with a cup of coffee in the morning. Will probably be buying more shortly!
Reviewed by mneiss
mneiss bought "Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll" on our website
09/20/2017 - 03:24:13 PM
Forgot they were shipped.
I ordered 2 pumpkin loaves and we have been eating one of them. It is excellent .. There is a story behind this. The loaves came on Friday and were left on the back porch by the postal service. We had went away for the weekend on a mini trip. Came home to find them and they were still sealed and inside the original shipping box. It had been a cool weekend and they were still good. I wasn't sure how they would be, but like I said they were vacuum sealed and very fresh..
Reviewed by Linda McConahay
01/24/2017 - 09:57:05 AM
Best ever!
I ordered for the first time for the holidays! I bought the Pumpkin Walnut, Apricot, Poppy Seed and Chocolate Walnut Kolachi! These were the best kolachi I ever had! I usually have to drive to Pennsylvania to get them from the store! I will be ordering yours from now on. They were fabulous! They have more filling than grocery store bought ones! I hope you sell the Chocolate Pecan again! I am allergic to walnuts now.
Reviewed by Customer_Testimonials
02/05/2016 - 05:32:55 PM
Huge Compliment!
Thank you for your prompt service. I just wanted to tell you that my German Grandmother used to make kolachkis from scratch. She mainly made the nut one and the poppyseed. She used to make them into pastries or the rolls. They were delicious. I remember her cooking the poppyseed filling. The ones I received from Butter Maid Bakery were equally as good. I ordered the pumpkin-nut one and the nut one for Thanksgiving and everyone liked them. I had never had the pumpkin-nut variety. Then I ordered the poppyseed variety and was a little skeptical that it would be as delicious as my Grandma's was. It was so good and filled with a good portion of the poppyseed filling. I sprinkled a little powder sugar on the top of it. It reminded me of my Grandma's so much and that is a huge compliment as she was an excellent cook. Anyway I just wanted to give you my testimonial regarding your products. Keep up the good work. - Jacqueline L, Palm Harbor, FL
Reviewed by Customer_Testimonials
10/25/2015 - 07:58:25 PM
Loved it
I ordered the Pumpkin Kolachi and we loved it. Getting ready to order more - Dawn McAdams, Terre Haute, In
Reviewed by Customer_Testimonials
09/20/2015 - 02:01:33 PM
The Pumpkin Nut Kolachi is amazing! I am so happy I ordered more than one! - Debby, Wildwood, Fl
Our Customers Say...

Just to let you know, I had your nut roll last week and it was delicious. Can't wait to try this. Too bad I didn't know about you before Xmas ! Nut rolls were always on the table during the holiday until I moved from Pa to Florida. I tried making them, but something was missing. Thanks for reminding me how good they should be...
Read More>>
Thanks for the quick service was not expecting it for a week but boy what a pleasant surprise to receive it today . We tried to resist till in the morning but had to break in to them this evening and man oh man they're all I remember from my grandmoms old kieffes she use to make at Christmas time Will be ordering more in the future for ...
Read More>>
Good afternoon, I felt the need to write to you this afternoon to express my sincere gratitude and appreciation for the wonderful customer service you provided to me recently. I am sure that people write often to express dissatisfaction, as I did a week or so ago regarding my first order with your company. I wanted to let you know that ...
Read More>>