Testimonials

Overall Rating: 98.13%
Average Rating: 9.81/10

My grand mother and Uncle Bob made poppy seed and nut roll every holiday. After they passed we occasionally receive some from small bakeries in Pennsylvania. Your roll is actually better than my grandmother and Uncle Bob's! (They didn't add as many nuts) My cousin ordered this for me as a surprise and now I'm hooked. I need to try the prune as my grandmother used to make one prune just for me. Thanks!
Debbie Rood, Okatie, SC
Been dreaming my way through my first order of honey nut, original nut, and poppy seed roll. Cheap time travel back to the joys of my long gone mother's and grandmother's kitchens. If anything, the Butter Maid stuff is even better than what we had as kids all those decades ago. Worth every cent. Another order just submitted.
Wackezoid, Las Vegas, NV
This is my 2nd order and as before I am extremely pleased. First, these goodies are from my home state of Ohio ❤️❤️.
Second, I am currently in a VA rehab hospital and placed an order for the nursing staff and other veterans.
Third, these were enjoyed by all and gobbled up quickly.
Of course, I told everyone these are from the best bakery in Ohio !!!
Thank you for another fabulous order!!!
Stephanie, Waco, TX
Just received my honey nut roll and it's delicious, packed with nuts.Ordered on the 12th and it was delivered on the 15th. I will recommend your bakery to friends. Thank you and Merry Christmas to you all!
Mary Louise, Pa
Kolachi is absolutely delicious and fresh! Sent as gifts and everybody loves it! I also love the military delivers and I made a donation - thank you so much for offering that service. Looking forward to ordering cookies in the future. The delivery was fast and the product arrived in perfect condition. Merry Christmas and Happy New Year!
Debbie, Ellendale, Delaware
Received my order and these are absolutely delicious I grew up On these and funny thing is that the company is from Ohio not to far from my home town I will keep ordering keep up the good quality
Mary Jo, Bradenton fl
Being Serbian I'm very familiar with the nut rolls but since losing my grandma and my aunt those days were gone until I seen your site on ETSY, you guys are the BEST!!!!
George, Chicago, Illinois
Thank you, thank you, thank you all for your wonderful Kolachi. My mother always baked them, passed her recipe down to all her children, but with busy lives and Holiday time constraints I ordered 9 Rolls which made their way to PA and TX, very quickly post ordering, wonderful shipping containers, and well received for Christmas to my three siblings. I have a cousin, Pam, in Warren who shops at our Bakery and highly recommended you, post my sending from two other online sites. There was the usual "skimpy", "too much dough" etc on these... one does know how Slovaks go on about their Kolachi, and my family is no exception.
However, one taste and the years melted away for all of them. I am happy to report back that your rolls are HUGE, not skimpy or too doughy, delicious walnut, apricot, and poppy seed fill were outstanding! They sampled and promised they were all freezing the remainder until Christmas.... hmmmm... I wonder if that will truly happen! Again, thank you. Your rolls will be my go-to from now on.
Dolores, Tallahassee, FL
Thank you, thank you, thank you all for your wonderful Kolachi. 9 Rolls made their way to PA and TX, very quickly post ordering, wonderful shipping containers, and well received for Christmas to my three siblings. I have a cousin, Pam, in Warren who shops at your Bakery and recommended you, post my trying two other years / two other online sites. There was the usual "skimpy", "too much dough" etc on these... one does know how Slovaks go on about their Kolachi, and my family is no exception.

However, one taste and the years melted away for all of them. I am happy to report back that your rolls are HUGE, not skimpy or too doughy, delicious walnut, apricot, and poppy seed fill were outstanding! They sampled and promised they were all freezing the remainder until Christmas.... hmmmm... I wonder if that will truly happen! Again, thank you. Your rolls will be my go-to from now on.
Dolores, Tallahassee, FL
Ever since we moved from PA to NY we searched for Nut rolls that compared to the local bakery in PA. After finding your company we don't have to search any further! I ordered the honey walnut roll and we ate it before the Holiday even arrived! I JUST ORDERED 3 MORE! Fabulous! THANK-YOU!
Marilee ~ Jim, Modena, NY

Submit Your Own Testimonial

Our Customers Say...

I just received the email from Butter Maid Bakery and couldn't believe anyone could order kolache online. I'm going to place my first order and can't wait to try them. I remember growing up going to my Grandmother's and we'd go to different bakeries and get different sweets. Seems there was a bakery on every corner back then. Plus they're made ...
Read More>>
My mother's family was from Poland via Scranton,Pa. She made Walnut Bread and Poppy Seed bread. She used a loaf pan.For years I have tried several brands of regionally made or mail order breads. I rec'd my first walnut-Kolachi and the taste is just like my mom's!!!! We will happily finish up this nut roll and then order the poppy seed!!!
Read More>>
You are good people. One of these days if I ever get back to my hometown, Youngstown, we would like to visit you in Boardman. Thanks for wonderful service and great Kolachi.
Read More>>