Butter Maid Bakery has been a small family owned and operated bakery since 1955. Our baked goods are handmade the old-fashioned way with simple ingredients, just like Mom & Grandma baked. We've been shipping Kolachi and other baked goods to all 50 states & Military addresses for over a decade, from our bakery right here in Youngstown, Ohio. When you order baked goods from our kitchen, we're going to treat you like you're here for Sunday dinner. We put immeasurable care into everything we do, and are truly committed to baking and delivering the highest quality products. "It's Better Made If It's Butter Maid" Read Our Story
Our Customers Say...

I have been searching for potica, made for years at the Slovenian Catholic Church (Holy Trinity) in Indianapolis. I decided to give Butter Maid Bakery a try and ordered some to be served for Easter. We were not disappointed. Though the roll is flattened somewhat from being shipped airtight, it's taste is first rate. I shared a loaf with ...
Read More>>
I buy a raspberry walnut and a apricot. I rated a 3 cause when you say apricot that's what I want. i'm a true apricot lover. my apricot preserves have more favor. as for the dough beautiful.
Read More>>
I have checked out your website many times but never ordered. Then I came across your ad on facebook and thought it was time to order and try out your products. Wow, am I glad I did! I bought The Original Nut Kolachi Roll, Honey Walnut Kolachi Roll, Apple Cinnamon Nut Kolachi Roll and Sea Salted Caramel Chocolate Cookies. First thing I was ...
Read More>>