Butter Maid Bakery is a 5th generation small family owned & operated bakery. Our products have been handmade the old-fashioned way for over 150 years, since 1903 in our first Ohio bakery and 1800s bakery in the old country. We use the finest ingredients: Real sugar, honey, butter, eggs, milk and nuts directly from the farm. We put immeasurable care into everything we do and are truly committed to baking and delivering the highest quality products. "It's Better Made If It's Butter Maid" Read Our Story
Our Customers Say...

I ordered Kolachi cookies for my mother's 85th birthday with the hopes that they would be like the ones her Hungarian mother used to make when she was young. She LOVED them and said they were exactly like the ones her mother made. We were so impressed with how quickly they shipped and how delicious they were.
Read More>>
I grew up in Pennsylvania and Judy Jean Pastries made the "nut roll". I have since moved away and they have closed. I have been searching for the specific taste and The Butter Maid Bakery has it. As soon as I took the first bite of the Kolachi all the memories of home and my mother came flooding back to me. As a special treat add a slice of ...
Read More>>
Great Navy Cookies I had you send my grandson 10 DOZEN cookies! He is on the destroyer USS Bainbridge (DDG 96) and he said the cookies lasted 15 minutes! Thanks so much for what you do. The packages from "home" are so appreciated by our soldiers, sailors and all the military. Bless you all.
Read More>>