Butter Maid Bakery is a 5th generation small family owned & operated bakery. Our products have been handmade the old-fashioned way for over 150 years, since 1903 in our first Ohio bakery and 1800s bakery in the old country. We use the finest ingredients: Real sugar, honey, butter, eggs, milk and nuts directly from the farm. We put immeasurable care into everything we do and are truly committed to baking and delivering the highest quality products. "It's Better Made If It's Butter Maid" Read Our Story
Our Customers Say...

Thank you! I ordered last month for a friend and she just loved it! Said omg I have been searching for nutrolls like everyones grandma used to make. She said the cookies were better than homemade!
Read More>>
I can't tell you how excited I am to find your website! I grew up in Sharon,PA and worked at Max-Ann Bakery in Hermitage. They made the best kolachis, and I had given up finding anything like them here in Rochester, NY. It's only when I go home (or my sister comes up) that I buy them, as well as cream horns, etc. at Hermitage Bakery! Now I can ...
Read More>>
Just a note to let you know that our order arrived this morning. We are sampling the Prune Leckvar and it is super. Haven't had that in a long time actually since we lived in Boardman back in the early to mid 70's. My wife's grandmother and mother in Pittsburgh both made Kolachi and yours rivals their homemade ones. Thanks very much!
Read More>>