Butter Maid Bakery has been a small family owned and operated bakery since 1955. Our baked goods are handmade the old-fashioned way with simple ingredients, just like Mom & Grandma baked. We've been shipping Kolachi and other baked goods to all 50 states & Military addresses for over a decade, from our bakery right here in Youngstown, Ohio. When you order baked goods from our kitchen, we're going to treat you like you're here for Sunday dinner. We put immeasurable care into everything we do, and are truly committed to baking and delivering the highest quality products. "It's Better Made If It's Butter Maid" Read Our Story
Our Customers Say...

I received my order today. My 93 year old mother, who lived in Poland on her own til she was 91, when she became unable to be on her own, now is living near me in Columbus. It was never really Christmas at her house unless there was a Youngstown cookie tray. You will have made her holidays complete!! The tray looks gorgeous and the kolaches ...
Read More>>
Thank you! I ordered last month for a friend and she just loved it! Said omg I have been searching for nutrolls like everyones grandma used to make. She said the cookies were better than homemade!
Read More>>
I can't tell you how excited I am to find your website! I grew up in Sharon,PA and worked at Max-Ann Bakery in Hermitage. They made the best kolachis, and I had given up finding anything like them here in Rochester, NY. It's only when I go home (or my sister comes up) that I buy them, as well as cream horns, etc. at Hermitage Bakery! Now I can ...
Read More>>